Netflix subscribers have delivered a shocking verdict, naming a romantic drama with a seemingly strong critical rating as one of the worst shows of the year. The backlash centres on the second season of Nobody Wants This, which fans have labelled 'unwatchable' in a popular online discussion.
From Critical Darling to Fan Disappointment
The show, starring Kristen Bell and Adam Brody, premiered in 2024 to widespread acclaim. It follows podcaster Joanne (Bell) and rabbi Noah (Brody) as they navigate a relationship despite their clashing lifestyles. The first season earned a stellar 95% score on Rotten Tomatoes from critics.
However, the mood shifted dramatically when season two arrived on Netflix in October 2025. Fans took to a Reddit thread asking for the "worst/most disappointing Netflix shows of 2025" to voice their frustration. The consensus was that the new instalment had "lost its charm" by simply rehashing the original plot without innovation.
Audience Scores Plunge as Critics Remain Kinder
The data reveals a stark divide between professional reviewers and the viewing public. While critics on Rotten Tomatoes gave season two a 79% rating, the audience score plummeted to just 53%. This brought the show's overall critical average down to 87%, a figure that now masks significant viewer discontent.
One disappointed fan summarised the feeling, writing: "I loved S1 so much. S2 just repeated the same storyline." Another agreed, stating bluntly: "S2 was unwatchable. Nobody wants a S3!" Further comments described the lead character as "insufferable" and criticised the season for having "no storyline."
Third Season Confirmed Amidst Backlash
Despite the harsh fan reception, Nobody Wants This is confirmed to return for a third season in 2026. This sets up a crucial test for the series: can it recapture the magic of its first season and win back alienated viewers, or will it cement its reputation as a show that failed to live up to its early promise?
The entire discussion highlights the growing power of audience feedback in the streaming era, where high-profile algorithms and critic scores can sometimes clash with the visceral reaction of a dedicated fanbase. Nobody Wants This is available to stream in full on Netflix now.
