Harry and Meghan threatened to sue BBC over Lilibet name row
Harry and Meghan threatened to sue BBC over Lilibet row

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle threatened to sue the BBC after it reported that the late Queen was not asked permission to use her childhood nickname for their daughter's name. The Duke and Duchess of Sussex accused the broadcaster of libel over the story.

The dispute resurfaced during the latest episode of the Daily Expresso podcast, when royal author Robert Hardman recalled the legal drama surrounding the naming of Princess Lilibet. Mr Hardman, who wrote Queen of Our Times: The Life of Elizabeth II, was discussing the impact of royal scandals on Queen Elizabeth II, including his thoughts on how she would have responded to the so-called "difficult dukes", Prince Harry and Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor, the former Duke of York.

Queen's reaction to the name

Mr Hardman told the podcast the Queen was not particularly bothered about the name being used, although it surprised some members of the Royal Family. He said: "What upset the Queen was that, having decided to call their daughter Lilibet - and they told her - the BBC then reported that the Queen had not approved this, and they [Harry and Meghan] shot back immediately with lawyers' letters and basically threatened to sue the BBC."

The author added that the Sussexes wanted Buckingham Palace to support their version of events. He continued: "And surprise, surprise, the Palace said no." Mr Hardman suggested Harry and Meghan assumed the Queen approved the use of the name, but added: "It's one thing to sort of ring up and go, 'Hey granny, we're going to call our daughter Lilibet'. You might say, 'Oh well, that's nice', but it doesn't mean you've approved it. You haven't been given any choice. You've been notified."

Legal letters and Palace response

He said: "So what the Queen and the Palace didn't like was the Queen basically being ordered to support a version of events that wasn't their version. As the Queen famously said in other circumstances, 'recollections may vary', and they certainly varied on that one."

In June 2021, Harry and Meghan instructed lawyers to inform the media that the BBC story was "false and defamatory". A spokesman for the Sussexes said at the time that the Duke spoke to his relatives ahead of the name announcement and the Queen was the first family member he told. The spokesman said Harry shared his and Meghan's hope of naming Lilibet in the Queen's honour, and that if she had not been supportive, they would not have used the name.

Background to the naming

At the time, the decision to use Lilibet was widely viewed as a bid on the Sussexes' part to heal a rift with the Royal Family in the wake of their interview with Oprah Winfrey, in which they made an allegation of racism against an unnamed member of the family. A source told The Sun that Harry did not ask the Queen for permission and the news of the naming was "simply presented" to Elizabeth II. The BBC reported that a Palace source was "absolutely adamant" the Queen was not asked if she approved of the name.

Lilibet was the Queen's nickname among members of the Royal Family from childhood. It was coined when Elizabeth was a toddler and unable to pronounce her full name. Her grandfather, King George V, called her Lilibet after imitating her own efforts to say her name, and it stuck, including with her late husband, Prince Philip, who used the nickname.