Reality television star Kim Kardashian has found herself at the centre of a significant controversy after being seen carrying a Hermès Birkin bag reportedly crafted from elephant skin. The accessory featured prominently in her new Hulu series, All's Fair, sparking immediate backlash from viewers and celebrities alike.
Ireland Baldwin's Furious Reaction
The most vocal criticism came from model and activist Ireland Baldwin. Taking to her Instagram Stories on Tuesday 25 November 2025, Baldwin did not mince her words, publicly labelling Kardashian's choice of accessory as "disgusting and shameful". Her public condemnation amplified the issue, bringing it to the attention of a much wider audience and fuelling the online debate.
The Details Behind the Controversial Accessory
The bag in question is a highly exclusive Hermès Birkin. Investigations into its origin suggest it was a custom order from the 1980s. It is crucial to note that the luxury fashion house Hermès has never officially sold elephant leather bags to its general customer base, making this particular item an extreme rarity. While some fans online speculated that a stylist for the show might have selected the item, the responsibility for its use on her platform ultimately fell on Kardashian, leading to widespread outrage among her followers and animal rights advocates.
Fallout and Unexpected Success
Despite the furore over the elephant skin bag, the show itself has proven to be a success with audiences. All's Fair managed to secure strong viewership numbers, leading to its renewal for a second season. This commercial victory came in stark contrast to the overwhelmingly negative critical reviews the series received from professional critics, creating a complex narrative of public appeal amidst ethical controversy.
