Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim's documentary You Can See Everything, about Theranos fraudster Elizabeth Holmes, is a full-on head trip that tries to figure out the mindset of both its subject and its director, who appears onscreen throughout. The film, which runs 2 hours and 54 minutes, has already swept the major prizes at the Critics Choice Documentary Awards and is being tipped for a possible best picture nomination at the Oscars.
A bizarre premise with radical transparency
Holmes became more famous through an HBO documentary on her fall from grace as a young female self-made billionaire in the tech space, and then through The Dropout, an award-winning Disney+ mini-series starring Amanda Seyfried as Holmes. Fielder actually plays Seyfried at one point in one of the film's most expertly uncomfortable scenes.
The documentary promises 'radical transparency and as much access as possible', a promise made by Holmes's fiancé Billy Evans. That access includes an unasked-for, full-frontal shot of Billy in the shower, which the reviewer says somehow makes complete sense by the time it arrives. Fielder even moved in with the family for the last two weeks of filming.
Audacious filmmaking and cultural moment
The film is enjoying a cultural moment that feels akin to that of Barbenheimer, the colossal clash of two blockbuster releases in 2023, which is quite something for a documentary. The hype has been huge ever since the much-parodied 'why would I deceive you?' moment from the trailer, which showcases how unnerving and hilarious many of Holmes and Fielder's exchanges are, writ large in intense close-ups of their faces and her huge blue eyes.
Fielder and Oppenheim got A24 on board under an agreement that they could scrap the film if nothing came from it. Instead, they have presented an extraordinary investigation of a subject that finds ways to work under the trickiest circumstances – like when Holmes heads off to start her 11-year prison sentence not even halfway through.
Verdict and release
The reviewer notes a slightly slow, fluffier start that could test patience, then makes way for one of the most audacious, narrative-bending films they've seen, following its own rules throughout. They call it a true original. The film premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 6, released in the US on October 16, and releases in UK and Irish cinemas on November 20.