Netflix's new documentary Primetime Preacher$ examines the rise of televangelism in America, a movement that became a dominant force on US television and produced a series of shocking tabloid scandals. The film, directed by Joe Berlinger, focuses on three central figures: Jerry Falwell, Jimmy Swaggart, and Jim Bakker.
Berlinger, known for his true-crime documentaries on figures like John Wayne Gacy and Jeffrey Dahmer, initially saw this project as a departure from his usual subject matter. However, he found that the story of televangelism was itself a compelling crime story, intertwined with the political rise of the religious right. "The deeper resonance for me came when I realized that the global televangelism rise actually mirrors the rise of the religious right," he says. "Religion and politics, from Reagan on, has really changed politics for the worse in my opinion. This was the birth of that."
The Rise of the Prosperity Gospel
In the early 1970s, roughly a quarter of US adults identified as evangelical Christians. As televangelism expanded, so did the appeal of the prosperity gospel, the idea that personal wealth was a sign of divine favor. This encouraged followers to tithe generously to the church and its ministers.
The documentary centers on Falwell, the leader of the "moral majority" and founder of Liberty University; Swaggart, the Pentecostal preacher known for his theatrical sermons; and Bakker, who lost his PTL ministry after an extramarital affair and a federal fraud scandal. Berlinger describes their intertwined story as "a fun little Shakespearean tale of ego, greed and ambition."
Scandals and Downfalls
Bakker anchors the 114-minute film. Archival footage and interviews with associates and the Pulitzer prize-winning Charlotte Observer team show how he used folksy charm to build a satellite audience of more than 13 million people. Behind the scenes, Bakker and his wife Tammy Faye lived a life of luxury, with homes, a private jet, and a pair of facelifts for Jim.
Swaggart, who called Bakker "a cancer on the body of Christ," was later caught in a tryst with a sex worker in New Orleans. Falwell, who took over PTL after Bakker resigned, publicized the ministry's financial improprieties and ultimately walked away from a business that was more than $65m in the hole.
Political Impact and Legacy
The film shows how these scandals drove a broader political conversion. When Bakker faced questions from Jimmy Carter's Federal Communications Commission over PTL's fundraising, he lent his platform to Ronald Reagan. In the nearly half century since, the movement has become a cornerstone of the GOP coalition, helping elect every Republican president since Reagan, including Donald Trump.
Only Tammy Faye Bakker emerges as a redeemable character. After divorcing Jim, she became an LGBTQ+ ally before dying from cancer in 2007. Her son Jay Bakker, who is LGBTQ-affirming, opened a rift with his father that did not close with Jim's death. The documentary notes that today's TV megapastors have learned from Bakker's mistakes, openly asking for jets and claiming it's God's will. "It's amazing people give under those circumstances," Berlinger says. "But people want to believe, you know?"