Mahershala Ali's new thriller doesn't do his action-hero talents justice
Mahershala Ali's new thriller doesn't do his action-hero talents justice

Mahershala Ali delivers a tortured performance as a grieving husband and devoted father in Your Mother Your Mother Your Mother, but the thriller's pacing and structure leave his action-hero potential underused. The film, directed and written by Bassam Tariq, is built around an Islamic hadith that emphasises a mother's importance, a theme that drives the story of a hitman forced to care for his children after his wife's death.

The movie opens with hitman Latif (Ali) killing an adversary, but the inciting incident is the death of his wife, the mother of his children. Latif, whose religious devotion matches his assassin skills, must now raise his children as a mother would. With a newborn reliant on breastmilk, he sets aside his swords and begins a frantic search for milk for his wailing baby.

A plot that plods

The film's pacing is its biggest weakness. Long sequences with slow plot progression threaten to lull viewers to sleep, punctuated by scant action scenes that feel more like a checklist than a meaningful part of the story. It is difficult to fully understand Latif's relationship with being a professional killer because the story begins when he is ready to leave that life behind, making the violence seem begrudging.

The movie would have benefited from more exploration of his deadly career through the lens of his religion, but instead these two fundamental parts of his life feel achingly separate. The eldest daughter, Faith (Adia), acts toe-to-toe with the Oscar winner, providing a shoulder for her father and carrying the burden of worry for her family.

A showdown that hits too hard

The final epic showdown is executed well enough, though it hammers the deeper message about fatherhood and divinity rather than trusting the audience to read between the lines. By the end, the thriller aspect feels disjointed from the rest of the movie in an unsettling, slightly jarring way.

For those hoping this film would fill the gap left by Mahershala's exit from Blade, it is unlikely to do the trick. The quiet bubbling of potential throughout never comes to fruition, as the movie prioritises an urgent story about fatherhood at the cost of Mahershala as an action hero.

Verdict

Despite the pacing issues and occasionally clunky plot, this is a compelling tale of devotion in all its forms and will add another notch to Mahershala's decorated belt. Your Mother Your Mother Your Mother premiered at the BFI London Film Festival and will be released in UK cinemas on November 20, 2026.