A Levenshulme pub has had its premises licence suspended after police reported violent incidents outside the venue, including an eight-minute brawl involving up to 15 people. The decision was made at a Manchester council licensing hearing on Thursday, November 19.
The Horseshoe, on Chapel Street, faced the hearing after Greater Manchester Police raised public safety concerns following two recent incidents outside the pub. CCTV footage shown at the hearing depicted an incident on Saturday, November 7, just after 2am, when a group appeared to gather outside the pub after closing time.
Police describe 'large-scale disorder'
PC Stuart Hammersley told the hearing: "Up to 15 people [were] involved in large-scale disorder. We saw punches, kicks, people thrown to the floor... and this continued on for about eight minutes."
One victim was taken to hospital with a suspected fractured eye socket, and a Section 20 wounding crime has been recorded and is still being investigated, the force confirmed after the hearing.
PC Hammersley also said the venue did not immediately provide CCTV footage of the incident when asked, and that it took eight days to be shared with police. He added: "I think we feel that the violence alone from that incident isn't just what undermines the licensing objectives, we also feel that the hindering of the investigation by the staff and their unwillingness to provide the CCTV undermines the licensing objectives further."
Second incident during police visit
A further visit to the pub was arranged on Saturday, November 14, by GMP and Manchester council's licensing and out of hours teams. PC Hammersley said: "As we arrived at the premises and parked up outside, it was about 20 past 11, and prior to getting out of the vehicle, a further incident of disorder took place." CCTV footage of this second incident was also shown at the hearing.
Callum Gallagher and Jacqueline Forrest attended the hearing as managing tenants of the pub, which they said is owned by Stonegate. Ms Forrest is the premises licence holder and designated premises supervisor, according to Manchester council's licensing report. A Stonegate representative was not present at the hearing.
Ms Gallagher said CCTV footage was not refused to police, but that he had to go through a process by first asking Stonegate, as set out in his contract with the company. Stonegate said there are no clauses to this effect in its agreement with Mr Gallagher.
Tenants dispute police claims
Mr Gallagher claimed the person taken to hospital following the November 7 incident was injured further down the A6, away from the pub. He told the meeting: "In terms of summarising all of this, the failure to actually cooperate with the police we completely disagree with.
"We are under strict instruction by Stonegate that we have to follow a process under the Data Protection and GDPR rules that we have to get approval before we can distribute any CCTV. Personally, I don't agree with it."
Mr Gallagher described the incident on November 7 as 'horrendous' and said steps were being taken, including the future provision of security staff. He also said he had not been aware of a licensing objective about stopping customers being let into the pub after 10.45pm, adding: "I will be the first person around this table to hold my hands up and say I was not 100 per cent aware of that, 10.45pm as a last let-in, I think we both agree we didn't really know that was there."
Mr Gallagher asked councillors to allow the pub to continue operating while the concerns are addressed. PC Hammersley said: "We would ask the licence is suspended pending a full hearing, we feel it's the only way the licensing objectives can be upheld, and for public safety for the customers of the premises to be looked after in the interim."
Councillor Lee Glover said: "After a discussion we have made a decision to suspend the licence." A full review of the premises licence will take place, likely on December 9, according to Manchester council's legal representative at the hearing.