Teacher and Ex-Prison Guard in Child Sex Cases Are Neighbours
Teacher and Ex-Guard in Child Sex Cases Are Neighbours

Two women facing separate child sex crime charges lived next door to each other in a small rural Kentucky town, according to addresses on their criminal indictments. Mary 'Hanna' Mattingly, 32, admitted having sex with an underage student while working as a teacher in Bardstown. One door down lived Lauren Winans, 31, a former prison guard arrested last month on multiple child sexual abuse and incest charges. It is not clear if the women knew each other.

Both Women Share Similar Profiles

Both are wives, appear to have young children, and have similar dyed blonde hair with a middle parting. Court documents alleged Winans committed incest by having sexual intercourse or deviate sexual intercourse with a person she knew to be an ancestor under 12 years old between January 1 and November 20, 2002. She also faces two counts of first-degree sexual abuse and one count of sodomy against a victim younger than 12 within the same period, reports the New York Post.

Winans' relationship with the alleged family member has not been disclosed. She has remained in custody on $250,000 bail since her October 22 arrest and has entered a not guilty plea. She married Andrew Winans, a current Bardstown police officer, in June 2024, years after her alleged crimes.

Teacher Pleads Guilty in Separate Case

Mattingly broke down in tears on Friday while pleading guilty to first-degree sexual abuse of a 16-year-old student and possessing naked photos of him portraying a sexual performance of a minor. The married substitute teacher, who has at least one child, is expected to receive a five-year prison sentence under a plea agreement ahead of her January 21 sentencing.

Court records show she asked the male student to help clean the girl's locker room, where they would sit and chat about her life. The student told police they began talking on Snapchat and had sex between March 1 and July 31, 2025. Mattingly was arrested in March and fired from Bardstown High School after an anonymous tip about inappropriate conduct, including sexual contact, between her and a student. Police found she communicated with the student electronically, including sending partially nude photographs.