Jade Croucher has described the harrowing phone call in which she begged her brother Haydon not to take his own life, months after their sister Leah disappeared in February 2019. Haydon, 24, ended his life in November 2019, just nine months after Leah vanished on her way to work in the Furzton area of Milton Keynes, Buckinghamshire.
In her first newspaper interview since the double tragedy, Jade, 32, said Leah's disappearance "ate him alive" and that Haydon could see no other way out. She recalled: "I got a phone call from Haydon and I could tell instantly by the sound of his voice that he wasn't OK. He was most certainly in absolute crisis, I could hear it, and my heart just dropped."
Plea to brother before line went dead
Jade said Haydon explained he could not cope anymore and knew something bad had happened to Leah. She pleaded with him: "Haydon, please, I need you as much as you need me. You are the only other person in this whole world that knows how it feels, please don't leave me." But the line went dead.
When their mother, Tracey Furness, arrived, Haydon was rushed to hospital in a critical condition, where he later died surrounded by family. Jade said Haydon's strong love for his family ultimately led to his demise: "Because when Leah disappeared, I feel like Haydon took on a lot of the burden of that. He so deeply knew something terrible had happened."
Discovery of Leah's body and Maxwell's crimes
Leah's dismembered body was discovered in the loft of an unoccupied home near where she was last caught on CCTV, after police had searched 3,500 houses and made only one cursory visit to the address where her body lay undiscovered for three years and nine months. Detectives later named convicted sex offender Neil Maxwell as the prime suspect in her murder.
Maxwell, 49, had snatched Leah off the street, raped and murdered her, then cut up her body and left it in bags in the loft of an empty house where he was working as a handyman. He had already been given four jail terms for sexual offences, including rape and child abuse, in 1998, 2002, 2009 and 2010, and was wanted for another offence at the time of Leah's murder. He took his own life two months after the offence.
Family campaign for 'Leah's Law'
Jade is calling for "Leah's Law" to introduce a "three strikes" rule, meaning sexual offenders would automatically be handed a jail sentence for their third offence. The legislation exists for other offences such as burglary but not for sexual offences. The family will meet Sentencing Minister Jake Richards this week in the hope he will introduce the rule.
An inquest in 2024 heard that Taekwondo black belt Leah tried in vain to fight off Maxwell. Senior coroner Tom Osborne called for a fundamental review of monitoring of sex offenders, saying failures in the monitoring of Maxwell by the probation service and police may have played a part in her death.
An online petition set up by Leah's family, including dad John, 52, and mum Claire, 51, has more than 125,000 signatures. It states: "Mandatory minimums exist for domestic burglary and Class A drug trafficking. There's no justifiable reason sexual offending should be treated more leniently. By a third conviction, the offender has not been sufficiently deterred from further offending."
Jade said: "The fact Maxwell was free and able to do what he did is horrendous, this law would change that. It would stop other people becoming victims like Leah. If Maxwell was treated in accordance with the law that we are proposing, Maxwell wouldn't have been up free on the streets. Maxwell would never have even been able to come in contact with my sister and Leah would still be alive, as would Haydon. I truly, truly hold Maxwell accountable for my brother's death. I will always, until the day that I die."
She added: "He hasn't only got the blood of Leah's on his hands, he's got the blood of Haydon too. They are both dead because of his actions. And if there was a law like what we are proposing he wouldn't have been free on the streets, he would have been in prison."
For emotional support, the Samaritans 24-hour helpline can be called on 116 123, or email jo@samaritans.org.