Florida killer Thomas Overton executed for 1991 triple murder
Florida killer Thomas Overton executed for 1991 murders

Thomas Mitchell Overton, 71, was executed at Florida State Prison for the 1991 murders of pregnant Susan MacIvor, her husband Michael, and their unborn child in the Florida Keys. He was pronounced dead at 6:19pm EST after receiving a three-drug lethal injection.

In his last words before the execution, Overton refuted any connection to the crime, stating: "I never killed anyone." He had received the death penalty for the slayings of Michael and Susan MacIvor, whose strangled remains were found at their Tavernier residence in the Florida Keys on 22nd August 1991.

Details of the Crime

Susan, who was eight months into her pregnancy, had also been sexually assaulted. Medical examiners determined that her unborn son likely remained alive for roughly half an hour after her death.

Overton was already secured to a gurney with an IV line inserted in his arm when the death chamber curtain was drawn back at 6pm. When given the opportunity for final words, he proclaimed: "I've never sexually assaulted anyone. I never killed anyone. I didn't kill the MacIvors."

Conviction and Evidence

According to Fox8 News, the lethal injection 'began immediately' after he had finished speaking. A warden then shook Overton and called his name, receiving no reply - a medic brought into the chamber subsequently pronounced him dead.

Despite collecting DNA evidence from the scene, investigators initially found it difficult to identify the culprit. Overton, who had worked at a local petrol station, was ultimately linked to the murders after being arrested on a separate burglary charge in 1996.

Execution Milestone

A DNA sample taken from him corresponded with evidence recovered from the MacIvors' residence. He was convicted of two counts of first-degree murder in 1999 and received death sentences for both crimes. His legal team had argued that investigators had fabricated the DNA evidence.

Thursday's execution marks a grim milestone for Florida, which has now performed 20 executions this year under departing Republican Governor Ron DeSantis. The former record was 19, established in 2025. DeSantis, who leaves office in January, has extensively utilised capital punishment during his time as governor, with two additional executions planned for December.