Detective Reveals Challenges in Rape Case Despite Lack of Evidence
Detective Details Rape Investigation Challenges

A detective has revealed how a rapist was brought to justice despite a lack of forensic evidence, CCTV, or eyewitnesses to the attack on a 16-year-old by the River Derwent.

Noah Burge, who identifies as non-binary, was raped by Nathan Longstaff in June 2023 at a remote spot near Winlaton, Gateshead, after a gathering to celebrate finishing their GCSEs. Noah, who has waived their right to anonymity, initially hid the attack for two months before reporting it to police.

Investigation Challenges

Detective Constable Phil Skeates, of Northumbria Police's Rape Investigation Team, said he immediately knew the case would present challenges due to the remote location and lack of forensic evidence. The offence occurred down by the River Derwent, where there is no electricity, no CCTV, and very little footfall.

"There were some elements of the initial investigation we couldn't review," he said. "Given the very rural location of the offence, down by the Derwent, there's no human infrastructure there other than the viaduct. There's no electricity, no CCTV and very little footfall in the area. Eyewitnesses and CCTV are both out and forensics are also out."

Despite these obstacles, Det Cons Skeates said the investigation focused on what evidence could still be available. "You are in this job because you have an investigative mindset," he said. "We conduct an initial review and you find yourselves ticking boxes in your head. You think 'that's out' or 'that's a maybe'. You see the potential challenges but you owe it to the public to do the best job you can."

Building the Case

Noah did not know Longstaff's name but had been told it by another person who was an eyewitness and willing to attend court. Det Cons Skeates visited the school Noah had attended, where the victim had been wearing a school leavers hoodie at the time, to build an identity picture.

Accounts were taken from all eyewitnesses who saw Noah running back to the group. All those involved were under 18, so parental or guardianship oversight was required for police contact. "It would have been very difficult to prove it was Longstaff that was there without these witnesses," Det Cons Skeates said.

When questioned, Longstaff was "unnervingly calm for a 16-year-old," according to the detective. "If I had been brought in on suspicion of rape at his age I would be beside myself. He was borderline nonchalant."

Consistent Accounts and Guilty Plea

During his interview, Longstaff admitted being at the gathering but denied being drunk or having any sexual contact. However, his alibis fell down when police spoke to his mother, who said he stayed at her house, and another witness described him as "mortal" despite his denial of drunkenness.

Accounts from family, friends, and professionals whom Noah had confided in were consistent, adding weight to the victim's credibility. "The professionals did their jobs perfectly. And the young witnesses made the case. And the suspect had the walls close in around them," Det Cons Skeates said.

Longstaff, who initially pleaded not guilty, eventually changed his plea to guilty and was sentenced to a three-year community order with 200 hours of unpaid work.