Police officers tasked with searching for two missing young women did not do a "proper job" and assumed they were out "partying" with friends, a misconduct panel has heard. Sophie Russon, from Newport, was in fact lying seriously hurt in a car crash in the St Mellons area of Cardiff which killed Eve Smith and two others and left another person badly injured, a Gwent Police misconduct hearing on November 17 was told. All of the victims lay trapped in the car for 46 hours before they were finally found.
Officers Deny Gross Misconduct Allegations
PC Richard Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone of Gwent Police face gross misconduct allegations over how they handled the missing persons report made on the day of the crash by the families of Eve Smith, who was later found dead, and Sophie Russon, who was seriously injured. Asked if he "did a bad job" when asked to follow up a missing person's report into Sophie and then lied about his actions because he failed to take the matter seriously, PC Richard Hardwick told the hearing at Rodney Parade, Newport that was not the case.
Sophie had gone on a night out on Friday, March 3, 2023, with Eve Smith, 21, Rafel Jeanne-Actie, 24, and Darcy Ross, who died, and Shane Loughlin, who was seriously injured but survived the crash. The accident happened early on Saturday, March 4, 2023, with friends Sophie, Darcy and Eve reported missing later that day. They were not found until early on March 6.
Report Suggested Women Were at a Party
Giving evidence on the second day of the hearing, PC Hardwick, 32, who was a probationary officer at the time of the incident, denied being dishonest in written and verbal reports and to an Independent Office for Police Conduct investigation, saying he had searched Sophie's home address and bedroom. The panel heard that PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone had been sent to Sophie's father's house, where she lived, and also to Eve Smith's family home in Newport at the start of inquiries when their parents reported them missing around 7.20pm on Saturday, March 4, 2023. They had gone to the women's homes at around 11.30pm.
It is alleged the officers failed to search the addresses, or the young women's bedrooms, as they should have done to get any possible clues about their disappearance. When they returned from speaking to Sophie's father Nathan Russon at his home, where she lived, the panel heard that PC Hardwick had written a report suggesting she was at a party and was low risk.
Father Accuses Officers of Lying
Questioning the officer, Stephen Morley, barrister for Gwent Police professional standards department, said to him: "On Saturday night you wrote that Sophie was believed to be at a party on Saturday night so you weren't carrying out hospital checks. Did you fully understand what you were dealing with and what you had been asked to do? Your entry suggests they were just out at a party and you were not going to do hospital checks. The risk level was put at low." He said the officer had written: "She had gone out with friends for a night out and not told her parents when she was coming home. Sophie is 21-years-old and able to make her own decisions if she stays out for the night."
Mr Morley went on to ask PC Hardwick whether he was referencing social media footage of the young women partying on Friday night and assuming this was still them on the Saturday, by which time they had been unaccounted for for 24 hours. Mr Morley asked PC Hardwick whether the reason he had not carried out adequate searches of Sophie's address, and not questioned why his colleague PC Livingstone had not allegedly searched Eve Smith's address, was because he deemed them low risk. "If you just thought she (Sophie) was at a party and parents not concerned is that why you did not do searches? Because you were not taking it seriously? Do you think it's possible you did a bad job because you were not taking this seriously or and did not fully understand? You have failed to do a proper job and have lied about it ever since." PC Hardwick said: "I disagree."
Earlier, Sophie's father Nathan Russon told the panel it had been an "absolutely horrific" time. He accused PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone of lying about what they did to look for his daughter. Mr Russon branded the two officers sent to his house at the start of the search as "liars". He told the panel that the two PCs had neither searched, nor offered to search, his address in Newport, where Sophie lived, or her bedroom. Mr Russon said: "They asked if I had seen or spoken to Sophie." Asked if PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone had also offered to search the house or his daughter's bedroom, he told the panel: "100% no."
Hearing Continues
The fatal accident is believed to have happened at around 2am on March 4, 2023, and the first missing person report in relation to the group was made at 7.20pm that day. However, the group were not found until shortly after midnight on March 6, in a wooded area off the A48 in St Mellons. Mr Russon told the hearing that later on when his daughter was in hospital he was angry. Recalling the tragedy and aftermath he told the hearing: "It was absolute chaos" adding "it was horrific. Absolutely horrific".
The panel was told that PC Hardwick took the lead at Sophie's address and PC Livingstone at Eve's. PC Hardwick admitted he could not recall searching Mr Russon's house or Sophie's bedroom there, but said he had searched her bedroom. Questioned by his counsel Sarah Barlow, he admitted he should have been clearer about this on written logs later, rather than stating "searches carried out". "I should have documented what I searched (for)," he told the panel.
The panel also heard from Sgt Lesley Cheverton, who told the panel that PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone, who she supervised, were reliable and she had no concerns about their work. They were not officers that she needed to keep an eye on. "I can't recall exactly the conversation I had with them after they went to the parents' homes," she told the hearing. "I asked them about social media checks and searches in the house, which I imagine I would have asked them about as well." Sgt Cheverton said she was told the properties had been searched and had no reason to doubt this. "They (PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone) are thorough," she told the panel.
PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone deny all the allegations against them. If found proved, the allegations could amount to gross misconduct and immediate dismissal without notice. PC Livingstone is due to give evidence at the hearing on Wednesday, November 18. The hearing continues.