Gwent Police officers failed to search for missing women, panel hears
Gwent Police officers failed missing women search, panel hears

Police officers tasked with locating two missing young women failed to do a "proper job" and assumed they were out "partying" with friends, a misconduct panel has heard.

Sophie Russon was in fact seriously hurt in a car crash in the St Mellons area of Cardiff, which claimed the lives of Eve Smith and two others, while leaving another person badly injured, a Gwent Police misconduct hearing on Tuesday was told.

All of the victims lay trapped in the wreckage for 46 hours before they were eventually discovered. PC Richard Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone, of Gwent Police, face gross misconduct allegations over their handling of the missing persons report filed on the day of the crash by the families of Eve Smith, who was later found dead, and Sophie Russon, who sustained serious injuries.

Officers' Actions Questioned

When asked whether he "did a bad job" in following up the missing persons report relating to Sophie, and whether he subsequently lied about his actions due to a failure to take the matter seriously, PC Richard Hardwick told the hearing at Rodney Parade, Newport, that this was not the case.

Sophie had embarked on a night out on Friday, March 3, 2023, alongside Eve Smith, 21, Rafel Jeanne-Actie, 24, and Darcy Ross, who died, and Shane Loughlin, who was seriously injured but survived the crash, reports Wales Online.

The collision occurred in the early hours of Saturday, March 4, 2023, with Sophie, Darcy and Eve reported missing later that same day. They were not discovered until the early hours of March 6.

Alleged Failure to Search

The panel was told that PC Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone had been dispatched to Sophie's father's home, where she resided, as well as to Eve Smith's family residence in Newport when enquiries began after their parents reported them missing at approximately 7.20pm on Saturday 4 March 2023. They had attended the women's addresses at around 11.30pm.

It is alleged the officers failed to search the properties, or the young women's bedrooms, as they ought to have done to obtain any potential clues regarding their disappearance.

Upon returning from speaking to Sophie's father Nathan Russon at his residence, where she lived, the panel heard that PC Hardwick had compiled a report suggesting she was at a party and posed a low risk.

Questioning the officer, Stephen Morley, barrister for Gwent Police professional standards department, put it to him: "On Saturday night you wrote that Sophie was believed to be at a party on Saturday night so you weren't carrying out hospital checks. Did you fully understand what you were dealing with and what you had been asked to do?"

"Your entry suggests they were just out at a party and you were not going to do hospital checks. The risk level was put at low."

He said the officer had written: "She had gone out with friends for a night out and not told her parents when she was coming home. Sophie is 21-years-old and able to make her own decisions if she stays out for the night."

Turning to the officer, Mr Morley asked: "Is that what you thought you were dealing with?"

"I guess yes," replied PC Hardwick.

'You have failed to do a proper job'

Mr Morley proceeded to question PC Hardwick on whether he had been referencing social media footage of the young women at a party on the Friday night and wrongly assuming this was still the case on the Saturday, by which point they had already been unaccounted for for 24 hours.

Mr Morley then challenged PC Hardwick as to whether the reason he had failed to carry out thorough searches of Sophie's address, and had not questioned why his colleague PC Livingstone had allegedly not searched Eve Smith's address, was because he had considered them low risk.

"If you just thought she (Sophie) was at a party and parents not concerned is that why you did not do searches? Because you were not taking it seriously? Do you think it's possible you did a bad job because you were not taking this seriously or and did not fully understand?"

"You have failed to do a proper job and have lied about it ever since."

PC Hardwick said: "I disagree."

The officer told the panel he had searched Sophie's room but could not recall its condition. He acknowledged he should not have logged that the property was searched when he had only checked her room, but insisted this was not intended to be deliberately misleading.

Earlier, Sophie's father Nathan Russon told the panel it had been an "absolutely horrific" time. He accused PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone of lying about their efforts to locate his daughter.

PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone of Gwent Police face gross misconduct allegations over their handling of the missing persons report filed on the day of the crash. They deny all the allegations against them.

Father's Account

Mr Russon branded the two officers dispatched to his house at the beginning of the search as "liars". He told the panel that the two PCs had neither searched, nor offered to search, his address in Newport, where Sophie lived, or her bedroom.

Recalling when he realised his daughter was missing, Mr Russon said he had not been initially concerned when Sophie did not return home from a night out on the Friday, as she had told him she was staying with a friend.

By Saturday afternoon he sensed "something is not right" when he noticed she had not been active on social media all day. He went first to her friend Darcy Ross's house and then Eve Smith's home address to check if his daughter was with them. When Mr Russon discovered Sophie was nowhere to be found, and that her friends were also unaccounted for, he and Darcy's mother Claire Ross made their way to Newport Central Police Station to report their daughters missing at around 7.20pm on Saturday 4th March.

Mr Russon told the hearing that much later that evening, PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone arrived at his home in Newport. He said the officers enquired whether he had seen or spoken to his daughter but failed to carry out any searches.

The hearing was told that initial searches of a missing person's address are crucial. Such searches can uncover vital clues including notes, missing clothing, and on occasion the missing person is discovered at home. These searches are a fundamental prerequisite for subsequent investigations, including requests for aerial searches.

Mr Russon said: "They asked if I had seen or spoken to Sophie." When asked whether PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone had offered to search the house or his daughter's bedroom, he told the panel: "100% no."

When questioned about PC Hardwick's evidence to a subsequent IOPC inquiry that he had appeared angry when the two officers arrived to speak with him, Mr Russon firmly denied this was the case. "Why would I be angry? It don't make sense. I was begging for help," he told the hearing.

When it was put to him that PC Hardwick had reported to the IOPC that he had been "effing and blinding", Mr Russon appeared visibly shocked. The panel heard that PC Hardwick had told the IOPC: "I would not say he (Mr Russon) was not upset. He was more angry, effing and blinding. F*** it, she's not turned up, that sort of thing." In response, Mr Russon told the panel: "That's 100% lies."

When asked about PC Hardwick's statement to IOPC investigators that: "He (Mr Russon) was happy for us to go and have a look and nothing looked out of place for a normal young girl's room" and "he (Mr Russon) could not tell us is any clothes were out of place or bags missing, that sort of thing", Mr Russon fired back: "100% he didn't ask me."

He went on to say: "At the time I was unaware he had come to search our house. I didn't have a clue until I spoke to the IOPC." When confronted with PC Hardwick's account to the IOPC that "He (Mr Russon) was showing us videos of them partying, drinking, being bubbly", Mr Russon dismissed this as "lies."

Officer's Admission

When pressed by PC Hardwick's counsel Sarah Barlow regarding the duration of the officers' visit to his home, and why he had stated in an email to the IOPC that he would have permitted a search, while also claiming he would not have done so as he knew Sophie wasn't there, Mr Russon said he could not recall.

Turning directly to the panel, he declared: "All I remember is them asking me if I had seen Sophie. My daughter was missing. I was asking for help. They are lying. I am sorry but that's the truth. He knows it and she knows it." Mr Russon added: "It feels like I'm on trial."

The fatal accident is believed to have occurred at around 2am on 4 March 2023, with the first missing person report relating to the group filed at 7.20pm that same day. The group were not discovered until shortly after midnight on 6 March, in a wooded area off the A48 in St Mellons.

Mr Russon told the hearing that he was consumed with anger when his daughter was later admitted to hospital. Recalling the tragedy and its aftermath, he told the panel: "It was absolute chaos" adding "it was horrific. Absolutely horrific".

The panel heard that PC Hardwick took the lead at Sophie's address, while PC Livingstone did so at Eve's. PC Hardwick admitted he had no recollection of searching Mr Russon's house or Sophie's bedroom there, yet maintained he had searched her bedroom.

When questioned by his counsel Sarah Barlow, he conceded he should have been more precise in his written logs, rather than simply noting "searches carried out." "I should have documented what I searched (for)," he told the panel.

Mr Morley then put it to PC Hardwick that he "never went near" Eve's room and did not search Sophie's room, despite claiming they had been. "There was no search that's the truth isn't it?" asked Mr Morley. "I can't comment," replied PC Hardwick.

Mr Morley suggested that the reason PC Hardwick had not challenged PC Livingstone over failing to carry out a search at Sophie's house was because, like him, she was doing "not a proper job". "When you got back to the station you made an entry - premise search conducted next to the form saying premises must be fully searched."

The panel also heard from Sgt Lesley Cheverton, who told the hearing that PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone, whom she supervised, were reliable and she had no concerns about their work. They were not officers that she needed to keep an eye on.

"I can't recall exactly the conversation I had with them after they went to the parents' homes," she told the hearing. "I asked them about social media checks and searches in the house, which I imagine I would have asked them about as well." Sgt Cheverton said she was told the properties had been searched and had no reason to doubt this. "They (PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone) are thorough," she told the panel.

Both PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone deny all allegations made against them. Should the allegations be upheld, they could constitute gross misconduct, resulting in immediate dismissal without notice. PC Livingstone is set to give evidence at the hearing on Wednesday November 18. The hearing continues.