Gwent PC breaks down in tears denying lying in missing women search
Gwent PC denies lying in missing women search

A Gwent Police officer accused of lying in the search for two young women, later found to have been in a car crash that killed three people and seriously injured two, broke down as she gave evidence to a misconduct hearing.

PC Lauren Livingstone, from Gwent Police, burst into tears several times under questioning on the third day of the hearing on November 18. The 27-year-old officer repeatedly denied lying in written reports, verbally or in later interviews to the Independent Office for Police Conduct about whether she and a colleague, PC Richard Hardwick, had searched the home of Eve Smith, who was killed in the crash, or Sophie Russon, who was seriously injured.

Officer describes shock and heartbreak

PC Livingstone told the panel of her "shock" and "heartbreak" when she learned what had happened to the missing 21-year-olds and their three friends, who were involved in a fatal crash in March 2023 but not found for nearly 48 hours.

The panel had been told that searching home addresses of people reported missing is a vital first step to finding them. Searches can uncover vital information such as whether clothes, bags and bank cards are missing or not, and whether there are notes left behind. This can indicate whether people intend to be away or not, or where they may be. The searches may also determine possible next actions such as aerial searches, the hearing was told.

It is alleged that PC Livingstone and PC Hardwick failed in their duty to search Sophie and Eve's home addresses, which they deny. Sophie's father Nathan Russon, Eve's mother Emma Borg and her brother Zaine Smith all told the panel earlier this week that the two officers visited their addresses on the night of March 4, 2023, but said they did not search them.

Probationary officers' first inquiries

PC Livingstone was still in her probationary period of training when she was sent to carry out initial inquiries at the homes of Eve Smith and Sophie Russon in Newport the night they were reported missing by their parents on Saturday March 4, 2023, the hearing at Rodney Parade, Newport was told.

Sophie and Eve, both 21, were among five people later found to have been in the car crash in the St Mellons area of Cardiff in the early hours of the same day. The crashed car was not discovered until the early hours of March 6. The delay prompted an inquiry into what took police so long to find them.

Driver Rafel Jeanne-Actie, 24, died in the crash alongside Eve Smith and Darcy Ross, also 21. Sophie Russon and another passenger Shane Loughlin were seriously injured. The Volkswagen Tiguan they were travelling in veered off the A48 in St Mellons, Cardiff, and crashed into a small copse of trees hidden from the road around 2am on March 4, 2023, the hearing had been told.

Denials over form filling

PC Livingstone and her colleague PC Richard Hardwick, also a probationary officer, went first to the home address of Sophie Russon, who lived with her father, and then of Eve Smith, who lived with her parents, to make the first inquiries after they were reported missing at Newport Central Police Station.

Gwent Police missing persons policy, which PC Livingstone said she knew "inside out", states that home addresses of missing people should be searched as they may provide vital clues, but she added that risk assessments are made on a case by case basis and on the information given from the control room and those reporting people missing.

Asked whether she had searched Eve Smith's home address or bedroom, or whether Sophie Russon's home and bedroom had been searched, where PC Hardwick took the lead asking questions, PC Livingstone told the panel that she could not say yes or no because she could not remember.

Asked if she had deliberately misled and been dishonest by implying in a form back at the station that Eve's house had been searched, when it had not, the officer denied that, saying she could not remember either searching, or not searching the addresses. Back at the police station she filled in the report form for Eve and PC Hardwick filled in the form for Sophie, the hearing was told.

PC Livingstone admitted the way she had filled in the section of the form asking whether Eve's address had been searched was "awful" but denied it was lying or deliberately vague because no search was carried out.

The panel was told that the entry read: "Nothing missing out of the usual that mum or dad were concerned over."

Stephen Morley, barrister for Gwent Police professional standards department, also questioned PC Livingstone on her risk assessment on the same form.

Filling in the missing persons report form for Sophie, PC Livingstone had noted: "They have gone out to what appears to be a party and stayed out longer than they should have been. Videos on Snapchat of the girls out drinking together and looks like they are in high spirits. The only matter of concern is that they are not contacting their friends."

She had then ticked a box asking if the disappearance was out of character to say 'no'.

"Out at a party?" Mr Morley asked PC Livingstone, adding that the video was from the Friday night and not the Saturday night.

"The video was from the night before but writing this it seems as if the girls are at a party when in fact the party was 24 hours ago and for the whole day no one was able to get hold of them."

Asked about this, PC Livingstone said she was writing her report on what she had been told and shown whilst at the homes of the two young women.

Officer insists she has not been dishonest

Becoming emotional she said: "I would never have thought what happened to those girls had happened. I would never have thought that."

"A tragic incident happened in which three lives were lost and two people injured. If I knew that I would have done anything."

"We are here for them today. I have not been dishonest. I have not done anything to hurt anyone. I really have not."

Crying audibly, PC Livingstone added: "I have not got it wrong."

The panel then heard how the officer learned of the crash when she was on one to one duty with a person in custody late the next day.

Asked how she felt on hearing what had happened to the two missing young women she had been sent to make initial inquiries about, she told the panel: "It was the first major thing I have ever been involved in. You go home and it's all over social media and you think 'oh my God what are they going through?'."

"As police you care. That's why we do the job."

Mr Morley suggested the huge impact of such an incident must be "seared" in her memory and suggested this would include her recall of whether or not Sophie and Eve's home addresses and bedrooms had been searched.

"You remember exactly what happened at those homes don't you?" he asked her, saying she took "the easy route" insisting to the panel that she couldn't remember whether they were searched or not.

PC Livingstone insisted this was not the case.

Mr Morley told the panel that an inspection of her form filling on other missing persons inquiries showed that 80% of the time she had been very clear on whether addresses had been searched or not.

PC Livingstone and PC Hardwick face allegations that they failed in their duties and then lied about what they had done in the search for the missing women. They both deny all the charges against them, which, if found proved, may amount to gross misconduct and see them dismissed from Gwent Police without notice.

The hearing continues.