A 95-year-old widow is facing a £1,000,000 court bill after a decade-long battle in a historic Kent village over a garden fence. The High Court has ruled that millionaire neighbours Neil and Fiona Morgan do not have to pay her legal costs, despite their 'deplorable and unacceptable' language during the case.
The row began in 2016 over the boundary between the Morgans' and Mary Egan's multi-million-pound country homes in Sissinghurst, near Tunbridge Wells. Over ten years of 'hostile litigation', Mrs Egan spent over £1m on lawyers, while the Morgans, who largely represented themselves, ran up a six-figure sum.
Dispute Over a 60-Metre Strip of Land
Mr Justice Tappin said the fight over a 60m-long sliver of grass, tree and scrub had resulted in 'expenditure of time, cost and energy wholly out of proportion to the financial value of the area of land in dispute.'
Barrister Daniel Petrides told the judge the dispute began when the Morgans decided to erect a new fence between their garden and Mrs Egan's land to the east. In September 2015, without prior consultation, they cut through the existing wooden fence and erected posts on Mrs Egan's land. After her solicitors sent letters about trespass, the Morgans removed the posts, bulldozed the fence, and erected another. Mrs Egan then cut down the second fence, prompting the Morgans to order a permanent fence with concrete posts, after which litigation began.
Conduct in Court Papers
During the case, Mr Morgan called a lawyer a 'lying hypocritical devious arse' and described his neighbour as 'malevolent' and 'all-knowing self-appointed royalty' in court papers. Mrs Egan's lawyer said she had been described as 'patronising', 'arrogant', 'malevolent' and 'frankly poisonous'.
The Morgans said: 'This wasn't about money. It never was. We put a fence up where there had always been a fence. We put it up because the old one had fallen down and our dogs and cats were getting out.'
Last week, Mrs Egan appealed against the costs decision, arguing that her neighbour's 'deplorable' conduct justified her seven-figure bill being paid by them. Mr Justice Tappin dismissed the appeal, meaning Mrs Egan remains liable for her own costs.