AMP NW Ltd, now Waste Solutions MCR Ltd, has been found guilty of corporate manslaughter after a waste picker was crushed to death by an excavator at a site in Dukinfield. Two staff members were also found guilty of criminal health and safety breaches.
Fatal Incident at Dukinfield Site
John Graveson, 42, was working as a waste picker at the site on the morning of March 3, 2023. He was walking through the yard, moving past an excavator driven by John Horan, the yard manager. As Graveson passed behind the excavator, Horan placed the vehicle into reverse and began manoeuvring backwards.
The excavator's reversing alarm was sounding and its blue warning lights were illuminated, but Horan remained facing forwards and failed to observe Graveson behind the vehicle. Within six seconds of Horan beginning to reverse, the excavator struck Graveson and crushed him, causing catastrophic injuries which killed him instantly.
Investigation and Court Proceedings
Greater Manchester Police and the Health and Safety Executive launched an investigation. They found that the excavator was fitted with a 360-degree camera system, which was not activated at the time of the collision. Its side mirrors were also folded in.
After a nearly two-month trial at Manchester Crown Court, on Tuesday (November 17) AMP NW Ltd was unanimously found guilty of corporate manslaughter by a jury. The company had pleaded guilty to failing to discharge general health, safety and welfare duty to an employee.
Horan, 34, of The Crescent, Worsthorne, Burnley, was found guilty of failing to discharge general health, safety and welfare duty to an employee as a staff member, but was cleared of gross negligence manslaughter. Company director Anthony Elston, 48, of Wicket Grove in Clifton, was also found guilty of failing to discharge general health, safety and welfare duty to an employee as an employer but was cleared of gross negligence manslaughter. Both will be sentenced on February 4.
'A Culture of Unsafe Practices'
Extensive CCTV analysis from the weeks and days leading up to the incident revealed a culture of unsafe working practices within the yard, GMP said. "Investigators identified repeated examples of pedestrians working in close proximity to moving heavy plant machinery, workers crossing behind reversing vehicles, personnel remaining in loading and tipping areas during vehicle movements, and individuals standing beneath suspended loads," they said.
"The footage showed that site manager Anthony Elston was present while these dangerous practices were taking place and that such practices had become commonplace on site. His failure to intervene or take effective action demonstrated a significant breakdown in the management of health and safety, amounting to a breach of the duty of care owed to employees."
Detective Chief Inspector David Moores from GMP's Serious Crime Division said that the incident had been 'waiting to happen'. "John Graveson went to work on 3 March 2023 expecting to return home to his family at the end of the day. Tragically, he never did," he said. "This was not the result of an unforeseeable accident. Our investigation uncovered an alarming pattern of unsafe working practices that had become normalised on site. The risks were obvious, persistent and entirely preventable."
John Graveson's partner Shelly described him as an 'incredible man' and 'loveable soul'. "John was an incredible man whose warmth and love left an indelible mark on everyone lucky enough to know him," she said. "He was a truly lovable, huggable soul who embraced life with a wide-open heart, finding his greatest purpose in the deep devotion he held for his daughter, his partner, his mum."