The family of Michelle Pearson, who was murdered in the Walkden firebombing along with four of her children, say failings by Greater Manchester Police, Salford council and housing bosses 'probably' contributed to their deaths, an inquest has heard.
GMP has admitted several failings prior to the fatal arson attack, including failing to attempt to arrest killer Zak Bolland hours earlier, but says the evidence heard by a coroner does not support the claim its inaction 'probably caused or contributed' to the five deaths.
Background to the attack
Lawyers for the family say Ms Pearson was 'left to manage her own risk' after being threatened by Bolland, who set fire to a wheelie bin and smashed her windows at her Jackson Street home, in the days leading up to the petrol bombing on December 11, 2017.
Mum-of-six Ms Pearson, 37, called police multiple times, told family social workers she wanted to move, and asked to be rehoused prior to the firebombing, the inquest was told. Three of her children - Demi, 15; Brandon, eight; and Lacie, seven - died at the scene. Lia, three, died three days later. Ms Pearson died in hospital 20 months on from the blaze.
Inquest proceedings
A seven-week inquest at Bolton Coroners' Court has examined the contact Ms Pearson had with GMP, Salford council social services staff and housing officials, as well as her treatment at Wythenshawe and Salford Royal hospitals and a care home.
Final submissions from lawyers for the family, police, Salford council and others were heard before coroner Timothy Brennand, who will deliver his findings on Friday, November 27. The hearing was told the only possible conclusion is that Ms Pearson and her children were unlawfully killed, but lawyers differ on whether other agencies could be found to have 'probably contributed to or caused' the deaths.
Bolland, 23 at the time of the attack, was involved in a 'tit-for-tat' feud with Ms Pearson's eldest son Kyle. His accomplice David Worrall and then-girlfriend Courtney Brierley were jailed in 2021. Bolland and Worrall were sentenced to life for the murders of the children in 2018, and were found guilty of Ms Pearson's murder at a separate trial in 2021. Brierley was jailed for 21 years for manslaughter.
Family's submissions
Anna Morris KC, representing the Pearson family, said the ultimate culpability for the 'heinous murders' was with the three perpetrators, but said there were 'missed opportunities' and 'cumulative failures' to stop and assess the risk the family faced from Bolland.
"This was not an arson attack out of the blue by an unknown perpetrator," she added. Ms Morris KC said Ms Pearson's allegation that Bolland had caused criminal damage and threatened to petrol bomb her home on November 26 was not properly investigated, and that he should not have been released with no further action taken.
The inquest earlier heard Bolland, on a suspended sentence for other crimes, walked free following a 12-minute 'no comment interview'. Ms Morris KC said a wheelie bin fire two days before the fatal attack, on December 9, was not properly investigated, highlighting that Bolland was not arrested. She added that police failed to arrest him again following an incident at the Pearsons' home hours before the firebombing.
"This failure left [Bolland] at liberty to carry out the fatal actions," Ms Morris KC said. Two hours later, Bolland returned to the Pearsons' home with Worrall and carried out the fatal attack.
Ms Morris KC said had officers attempted to arrest Bolland, it is 'likely that he would have been disrupted in his actions'. She said Bolland's threats could have been managed through the 'Threat to Life' notice process, and that strategy meetings should have been arranged to give police, children's services, housing providers and other bodies the chance to 'establish a shared understanding of the risk to the family'.
On Ms Pearson's care, Ms Morris KC said there was a lack of specialist burns care 'in a community setting', as well as a lack of specialist bereavement support. She told the hearing: "It has been said that Zak Bolland's behaviour was so unpredictable that it is speculative to say what difference police action would have made."
"That is a slightly fatalistic and passive approach to take from law enforcement and undermines the police's role. There were multiple missed opportunities to disrupt Bolland before December 11."
GMP's response
GMP made a series of submissions, as well as 'Tainton admissions' - formal acknowledgments of failings recorded during coronial inquests. On the Threat to Life issue, the force said the absence of a notice did not represent a failing on its part, insisting that any such notice would have 'resulted in exactly the same safeguarding measures as were already in place'.
Fiona Barton KC, on behalf of Chief Constable Sir Stephen Watson, said from Ms Pearson's call on November 26 through to the fatal attack on December 11, there was a 'clear pattern of escalation and opportunities to arrest' Bolland. There was 'insufficient recognition and escalation of vulnerability, repeat victimisation, cumulative risk and escalating offending behaviour' towards the Pearsons, she added.
The force denied the failure to arrest Bolland was 'probably causative', adding: "Had an attempt been made to arrest Bolland, it would be pure speculation to evaluate what the end result might have been." GMP accepted the investigation into the November 26 criminal damage and threats was inadequate, and that the investigation into the wheelie bin fire on December 9 was 'inadequate' and closed 'inappropriately'.
Ms Barton KC said the force had 'reflected forensically' on its actions, adding: "At the time these events took place, GMP was a failing force under special measures. It is now a level one force."
"It was an individual judgement that deemed Bolland's threats to be empty. If this same investigation were to take place today there would not be that single point of failure by a response officer."
Other submissions
Sophie Cartwright KC, for Salford council, said the town hall accepted a multi-agency strategy meeting should have been convened, which would have provided an opportunity for children's social care, GMP and other agencies to 'come together formally to share information, assess risk collectively and consider any additional safeguarding actions'.
The inquest earlier heard that following the attack, Ms Pearson spent 15 months on the specialist burns unit at Wythenshawe Hospital before being discharged to 3L Care, a nursing and residential care home in Atherton, Wigan, in March 2019. Around 10 weeks later, she was taken by ambulance to Salford Royal Hospital after staff 'reported they no longer felt able to continue to meet her requirements'. She was transferred back to Wythenshawe, where she died on August 25, 2019.
Coroner Mr Brennand referenced the evidence of Assistant Chief Constable Rick Jackson, who said there had been a 'clear acceptance' of 'not just one but several failings' by the force. The coroner will deliver his findings and record his conclusion on Friday, November 27.