A Florida jury has watched a deleted video from the phone of Dwain Hall, the 54-year-old on trial for the kidnap and murder of British woman Sonia Exelby, in which he directs her to say she wanted to be beaten and made to suffer.
Hall, who used the online user name Alpha Sadist, is accused of killing the 32-year-old from Southsea, Portsmouth. Prosecutors have told the court he was a predator who manipulated his mentally ill victim and stabbed her to death “for his own sadistic pleasure”.
Video played in court
In the footage, which had been deleted from Hall’s phone before being entered into evidence, Hall can be heard asking Ms Exelby why she was there and why she is “such an awful person”. She responds that she has “crushed everyone who ever loves me”.
Hall asks: “How did you want to die? What was your chosen way to die? Kind of describe that. What have you been consenting to here today?” Ms Exelby replies: “You mean the way that you’re talking about killing me? Yeah, is that what you mean?” After a delay she says: “Be stabbed.”
Hall then asks about her treatment over the previous days and what she had asked for, to which she says: “I can’t remember. We talked about so many different ways.” He asks what is on her face, and she replies: “You’ve beaten me.” When he asks if that is what she wanted, she says “yes”.
Investigation and discovery
Ms Exelby, who the court was told had a history of self harm and wanted to die, was reported missing from her home on October 12 2025, by which time police had established she had left the country. Her buried body was found by US investigators in Marion County, Florida, on October 17.
Hall was traced through the attempted use of Ms Exelby’s credit card by the roadside assistance company he owned. A police digital forensic examiner earlier told the court he had found images of rape, torture and murder on Hall’s phone.
The jury heard that after her body was discovered, Ms Exelby was found to have been stabbed four times in the left side, with wounds up to seven inches deep.
Hall’s statements to police
The jury also watched a lengthy video of Hall being questioned by investigators, in which he initially denied knowing Ms Exelby before making a full retraction to “clear my conscience”. He said he had been “mentoring” the 32-year-old online, “wanted to make her life better” and did not want her to kill herself.
Hall described his earlier, recanted statements as “Sonia’s cover story” and said she insisted she did not want to be a burden to him or his wife. He told investigators: “She just didn’t want to be disturbed any more. After she came here she wanted that to be it.” He added: “She did not want to be found. She did not want to be returned home.”
Giving evidence, Sara Exelby, who lives in Australia, said she had learned in 2023 that her younger sister had been communicating with “violent people on the dark web” and immediately contacted police. She told the court: “It was absolutely terrifying to think that she (Sonia) was in such a vulnerable state, and to think there were just these awful people out there who were taking advantage of her was just petrifying.” The mental health crisis team had also been alerted at the time. The trial continues.