A drama teacher at a Welsh secondary school has been cleared of all charges relating to sexual offences against a teenager. David O'Rourke, 44, who teaches at Whitchurch High School, was found not guilty by a jury at Newport Crown Court on Thursday afternoon.
O'Rourke had been suspended from his role pending the outcome of the legal proceedings. He faced nine charges: four counts of sexual activity with a child, three counts of causing a child to engage in sexual activity, one count of sexual activity in the presence of a child, and one count of inciting a child to engage in sexual activity.
Allegations and evidence
The complainant alleged that he and O'Rourke had engaged in penetrative sexual activity on one occasion, which the prosecution said the defendant found "exciting". In his closing speech to the jury on Thursday morning, prosecutor Andrew Davies said: "The prosecution say that the defendant besmirched the good name and trust in teachers by grooming and having sex with (the complainant)."
Character testimonies during the trial described O'Rourke as a well-liked teacher who helped pupils and staff members alike, and his abilities as an actor and performer were also praised.
Defence and verdict
The complainant told police that the defendant messaged him and they agreed to meet, but he was "feeling anxious". He said he and O'Rourke began having sex but he felt uncomfortable and told the defendant he "didn't feel right". The complainant said he stopped what he was doing but O'Rourke masturbated in front of him.
Mr Davies said: "The prosecution's case is the defendant was enjoying the experience and the risk he was taking in having sex with (the complainant). He was getting a kick out of that risk and it was (the complainant) who realised what they were doing was wrong."
The complainant reported the matter to the police around a decade later, and O'Rourke was arrested.
In his closing speech, defence barrister Jeffrey Jones said it was "one person's word against another" and there was difficulty in the late complaint as the defendant was unable to pinpoint his exact movements at the time of the allegation.
While giving evidence, O'Rourke was asked by Mr Jones: "When (the complainant) alleges you were kissing was that true?" O'Rourke said: "Absolutely not." Mr Jones said: "Did it move on to penetrative acts and oral sex?" O'Rourke said: "No it did not."
In cross examination, Mr Davies said: "You effectively groomed (the complainant)." O'Rourke said: "I did not do that, none of this is true and none of this has happened."
After the jury had returned its not guilty verdicts, Judge Williams discharged the case against the defendant and he was free to leave the dock.