A sheriff has found that the death of a 71-year-old prisoner could have been avoided had he been taken to hospital after first falling ill. Joseph Glass died at HMP Glenochil in May 2021 due to a heart condition, after prison staff initially refused to let him be removed by paramedics.
Glass was serving an 11-year sentence, which had an eight-year custodial element, after being convicted of assault and sexual offences against three girls in Clackmannanshire in 2018. His death while in custody prompted a fatal accident inquiry (FAI) at Kirkcaldy Sheriff Court.
Events Leading to Death
Scottish Ambulance Service (SAS) staff were called to HMP Glenochil at 8.40pm on May 14 2021, after Glass fell unwell and had difficulty speaking between breaths. An ambulance technician and an out-of-hours GP agreed that Glass should be taken to hospital.
However, a manager at the prison refused to allow Glass to be taken to hospital, saying that if he was not dying he should not leave the prison. Paramedics left at 10pm, but were called back twice the following morning.
Sheriff's Findings
When paramedics saw Glass in his cell for a third time around 8am on May 15, they pronounced him dead. His cause of death was later found to be a condition linked to heart disease.
Sheriff Robert More, issuing his determination on Thursday (November 19), said Glass could have been taken to hospital when paramedics first attended him, calling this a 'reasonable precaution' which could have resulted in his death being avoided. He said: “Mr Glass suffered a cardiac arrhythmia which occurred against a background of obstructive coronary artery disease.
“Had he been conveyed to hospital he would have been in a monitored clinical environment, with continuous cardiac monitoring and immediate access to resuscitation and defibrillation. If defibrillation had been delivered promptly, the arrhythmia would have been survivable.”
Response and Aftermath
After new joint guidance was issued by the SAS and the prison service on the handling of healthcare for prisoners, the sheriff made no recommendations. A Scottish Prison Service spokesperson said: “Our thoughts and condolences continue to be with the friends and family of Joseph Glass.
“Every death, whether in prison custody or in our communities, is a tragedy for all those who knew and supported the individual. SPS takes the learning from FAIs exceptionally seriously and implements changes for improvement.
“As Sheriff More noted, we have developed joint guidance on response to healthcare incidents, alongside the Scottish Ambulance Service, and he therefore made no recommendations.”
Procurator fiscal Andy Shanks stated: “I extend my condolences to the family and friends of Joseph Glass. This inquiry has identified circumstances in which this death might realistically have been avoided and highlighted failures in the systems operating at the time.
“Fatal accident inquiries are intended to ensure lessons are learned from tragic deaths and to help improve public services and protect lives in the future. The sheriff’s findings will be carefully considered by all those responsible for the care and treatment of people in custody.”