Pontins put profit before safety in fatal ceiling collapse, court told
Pontins put profit before safety in fatal ceiling collapse

A court has been told that Pontins put profit over safety after part of a ceiling collapsed, killing a 68-year-old woman. The incident happened in February 2019 in the Fun Factory area of the Brean Sands site in Somerset. Wendy Jones was one of 16 people injured when the ceiling fell; she was taken to hospital along with five others and died in August 2019 after spending six months there.

Prosecution details the collapse

Britannia Jinky Jersey Ltd, the parent company of Pontins, has admitted a charge under the Health and Safety at Work etc Act along with Stephen Bennison, 60, whose company carried out work on the ceiling. Prosecuting, Adrian Darbishire KC told Bristol Crown Court that Mrs Jones had gone to Brean Sands holiday park with family members, including her daughter and grandson, in February half-term 2019.

“On the evening of February 20, she was sitting in her mobility scooter in a communal area of the park known as the Fun Factory,” he said. “This is a large entertainment and bar area, with a suspended ceiling in which the ducting ran along one side. It was capable of hosting up to 1,000 people. That evening, a section of the ventilation ducting immediately above where Mrs Jones was sitting – along with a number of other people – collapsed on her. It caused her serious injuries.”

“She was one of 16 people who were injured in that collapse, including a baby or child in a pram, other children and other adults. She was taken to hospital. She never fully recovered, was never discharged from hospital and died on August 4 of that year.”

Soundproofing work and safety failures

Mr Darbishire said soundproofing work had been carried out on the ceiling by Bennison’s company, without proper risk assessment, following noise complaints from neighbours, in 2015. “Having carried out the work on the ceiling, having ordered far more of the insulation slabs which were required for the job, there was a problem about what to do with the leftover slabs,” he told the court. “In what seems to be an opportunistic move, it was agreed that Mr Bennison would put the slabs on top of the ventilation ducting.”

Mr Darbishire said the “whole job” had been carried out without proper planning or risk assessment, which he described as the company “putting profit before safety”. The court heard Bennison ran a sound and lighting company, mainly for events, and was cheaper to use than “a properly qualified expert” for the work carried out on the ceiling at Pontins. Each slab weighed around 4.5kg and they were installed at least two deep across the ceiling, though the exact weight placed on the ducting is not known, Mr Darbishire added.

In 2015, a general manager at Pontins Brean Sands emailed his concerns to head office that the ceiling “appeared to be sagging” under what he described as 16 tonnes of insulation tiles. A chartered surveyor reviewed the acoustic work in January 2016 and found it was not “adequately installed” and “could result in a collapse of the ceiling in a public area”, Mr Darbishire said.

Family's tribute and sentencing

In the days before the incident, witnesses noticed a “bulge” in the ceiling and reported it to staff but these concerns were not passed on to management, the court heard. On February 20 2019, Mrs Jones and her family went to play bingo in the Fun Factory at 6pm. Her daughter had gone to collect bingo cards when the ducting collapsed – leaving Mrs Jones with fractures to her left thigh, ribs, shoulder and a collapsed lung. She was taken to hospital but suffered blood clots and recurrent infections before her death in August that year. Injuries sustained to other guests included bruising, fractures and concussion, the court heard.

In a victim personal statement read to the court, Mrs Jones’s son James Havard-Jones said her “life was cut short by the negligence” of others. “An accident is something unforeseeable, this was not unforeseeable,” he said. “This was preventable. The risk existed and nobody did what should have been done to stop it.” He said his mother was “never the same again” after being injured and described how the family watched her “disappear before our eyes” in hospital. He told the court Mrs Jones was a mother, auntie, cousin, friend, carer, charity worker, community leader and grandmother to three children. “Whatever role she took on, she gave it everything she had,” Mr Havard-Jones said. “Her smile, warmth and kindness touched many lives. She simply wanted to make life better for other people.”

Representing Britannia Jinky Jersey Ltd, John Cooper KC apologised to Mrs Jones’s family. He said there “should have been” risk assessments and other documentation when the soundproofing work was carried out, but there was a “serious ignoring of process”. Alistair Haggity, representing Bennison, said his client wanted to “emphasise how sorry he is” to Mrs Jones’s family and to others who were injured in the incident. Bennison, of Farington, Lancashire, accepts the risk assessment he undertook was “not sufficient” and he is “racked with guilt” over what happened, Mr Haggity added. Mr Justice Moody is due to sentence the defendants, who have no previous convictions, on Friday morning.