A pathologist was unable to determine the cause of death of a woman whose dismembered body was found in a freezer, wrapped in tarpaulin and carrier bags, including a Wilko bag. Delia McInerney, 62, from Anfield, was discovered dead in George Gordon's flat on Gerards Court in St Helens in January this year, alongside her five guinea pigs, which Gordon is alleged to have drowned.
McInerney is believed to have been killed as early as April 2023, reportedly struck on the head with a hammer, just days before she was due to move to Portugal for a "new life." Gordon, 65, is on trial at Liverpool Crown Court, denying murder and causing unnecessary suffering to an animal.
Post-Mortem Examination
Dr Matthew Lyall, a pathologist, conducted a post-mortem at the Royal Liverpool Hospital on January 15. He examined the separated upper and lower sections of the body, several organs, and other fragments found inside a Wilko-branded carrier bag. Dr Lyall concluded that McInerney's cause of death was "unascertained," telling the court: "It's not because there was nothing to find, no factors which could have contributed to death or caused death. What made the examination more challenging is that the person had been dead for quite a long time, and they had been stored in a freezer and frozen for a period of time, then had to be thawed out."
He added: "Also, there was a lot of damage to the body. A lot of the body was disrupted, and many of the internal organs were in pieces. Although I have not been able to come to a conclusive cause of death, there are a number of considerations I am able to discuss."
Examining the head revealed a large area of bruising with three lacerations. Dr Lyall said: "The possibility that they could have been caused by a hammer was suggested to me. I believe they could have been caused by a hammer."
Mutilation After Death
Dr Lyall noted that the "extensive mutilation of the body… did not show indicators of a vital reaction," which would be expected if the mutilation occurred while she was alive. He said: "The majority, if not all, of this damage was caused after death. In view of the severity of the disruption, it would be unwise to rule out the possibility that this woman suffered a significant sharp force injury, including a stab wound, while she was alive, and such a wound could have caused or contributed to her death. Given the extent of the damage, it occurred to me that it was possible that the extent of the mutilation was deliberately caused to try to mask injuries that could have been there."
He also mentioned the possibility of asphyxia and discussed prescription drugs found in McInerney's system, stating: "The toxicology can't say how a drug has got into a person's system, whether she took them herself or they were administered to her. I would not be willing to say that this lady has died from drug toxicity, although it's possible she was under the influence of the drugs at the time of her death."
Defence Cross-Examination
Under cross-examination by defence counsel Gordon Cole KC, Dr Lyall admitted he could not establish "what was happening at the time those blows were inflicted," adding: "I think it's fair to say I can't say whether, in theory, she could have been lying on her back or standing up." When asked if McInerney "may have been involved in some physical altercation with the person who used the hammer," Dr Lyall replied "she could have been."
Regarding the three wounds to the top of the head, Dr Lyall said a single blow was possible only if the object had "three protruding components," but he considered that scenario "pushing it a bit." He described the scalp injuries as serious, saying: "It could be worse. But the scalp is split. I'd be very unhappy if that was my scalp."
Dr Lyall agreed that head trauma could explain her death, saying: "I think head trauma could explain her death, yes. It could be the initiator. That's possible." He also acknowledged that some injuries were likely inflicted after death, stating: "Some of it, I'm very confident. I have a concern that I have to express."
Prosecution's Opening
Martin Reid KC, for the crown, previously told the jury that police attended Gordon's flat on January 8 after concerns were raised about McInerney's wellbeing. He said Gordon had lied to friends about her whereabouts for over 18 months and sometimes pretended to be her in messages. Reid stated: "Unbeknown to them, but known very well to the defendant, Delia McInerney had died in April 2023 at the defendant's hands. Her dismembered body was found in a chest freezer in the defendant's flat on the 8th of January this year."
Gordon allegedly bought a sledgehammer and electric handsaw from eBay weeks before McInerney's death, stole thousands of pounds from her bank account, and took out a £10,000 loan in her name. The trial, before Mr Justice Goose, continues.