Man guilty of manslaughter after fatal Erdington attack
Man guilty of manslaughter after fatal Erdington attack

A man has been found guilty of manslaughter for a fatal attack in Erdington, after he initially tried to blame his girlfriend for the victim's injuries.

Michael Bennett, 39, was found unresponsive with serious injuries outside his home on Reservoir Road at around 1am on March 27. He suffered severe brain injuries and died in hospital two weeks later on April 10.

Trial and verdict

Kevin Siviter, 42, of Newcombe Road, Handsworth, was cleared of murder but found guilty of manslaughter following a trial at Birmingham Crown Court. The jury returned a majority verdict of ten to two.

Siviter was remanded in custody until January 18, when he is due to be sentenced.

Prosecution case

Prosecutor Tom Walkling KC told the court that Siviter sought 'revenge' against Mr Bennett because he had an issue with him. The trial heard that Siviter was 'obsessed' and 'fixated' with the victim, having gone to his address at least five times and looked through his rubbish before the fatal attack.

Siviter had also called the police 16 times about Mr Bennett, describing him to officers as a 'f****** animal' and saying: "I just need the police to deal with it because I will end up doing a long time."

Evidence and aftermath

Siviter and his girlfriend were captured on CCTV near Mr Bennett's home three minutes before the victim was found injured. Siviter then made a number of incriminating internet searches, including for 'one punch knocks out man' and 'one punch killer'.

He also messaged his girlfriend's dad saying 'got that guy last night', 'he's paid for it' and 'he's been sorted', as well as declaring 'I'm happy I got him'.

After his arrest, Siviter said 'I hope he dies' upon being told of Mr Bennett's grave condition, but denied inflicting his injuries. He gave multiple different accounts of what happened that night.

Sentencing

In court, Siviter claimed his girlfriend had scuffled with Mr Bennett and struck him with her phone, causing him to fall back off a wall and hit his head. Asked about his earlier comment to police that he wanted to kill Mr Bennett himself, Siviter denied meaning it, adding: "I've got a big mouth."

After the verdict on Tuesday, November 17, Judge Andrew Smith KC told Siviter: "I'm going to sentence you on January 18 next year. It will inevitably be a sentence where you remain in prison. The length and the form it will take is a decision I will take when I have further information about you. I have ordered the probation service to prepare a report on you to assist me in making the legal decision as to whether you are a dangerous offender."

The judge added: "You should cooperate with the preparation of that report. Were you not to cooperate that would be something indicating to me you may well be dangerous. It's in your interest to cooperate." Siviter replied: "Have a good day sir."