Prisoners at a Florida state prison testified about extreme heat conditions, with heat indexes reaching 119F, as part of a lawsuit alleging the heat contributed to deaths and constituted cruel and unusual punishment.
On Tuesday afternoon, Dwayne Wilson, 69, testified about the stifling heat at the Dade correctional institute, a concrete state prison south of Miami without air conditioning. Wilson, who is housed in the H dorms, a T-shaped building with one-to-two-person cells nicknamed “hell dorm” by prisoners, described the conditions. “It was so hot,” he said. “It’s so hot sometimes you have to put water on the floor just to try to keep cool.”
Heat sensors record dangerous conditions
The plaintiff’s law firm, the Florida Justice Institute, convinced a judge to allow 31 sensors to be temporarily installed throughout the prison during the summer of 2025. The sensors recorded temperature and humidity levels that Stefano Shiavon, a professor of civil and environmental engineering with expertise in thermal comfort, used to calculate the heat index. He found it to be above 88F (31C) 97% of the time, with the highest heat indexes often recorded at night, including one reading in the H dorm dayroom equivalent to 119F (48C) at 10pm one July day last year.
“The walls sweat,” Wilson said. “It’s miserable in the cell at night because, again, it’s so hot. No air comes to the bed we sleep at and the bed is soaked in sweat.”
Prisoners allege heat contributed to deaths
Wilson is among a group of prisoners who filed a lawsuit against the Florida department of corrections in 2024 for the conditions at the Dade correctional institution, alleging that the extreme heat contributed to four deaths. The bench trial began on Monday at a federal courthouse in downtown Miami. The case comes amid growing concern over extreme heat in US prisons, where more than 40 states lack statewide policies requiring prisons to provide air conditioning.
Gary Wheeler, 67, who was also housed in the H dorms, testified that just months ago he thought he was having a heart attack, but upon going to the medical clinic he was told by a nurse that he had heat exhaustion. “I am worried about dying. I feel like sometimes when I go to sleep at night I’m not going to wake up in the morning,” he said.
Death of James Beam
Both Wheeler and Wilson submitted informal grievances to the prison about the heat in the H dorms, some dating back to at least 2019. The men talked about another inmate affected by the heat named James “Jim” Beam, who was 83 years old, wheelchair bound, and had a respiratory condition. Wilson said one night he woke up when he heard Beam hollering for help from his cell. Wilson helped Beam back into his wheelchair and brought him to the medical clinic, where he was put on a breathing treatment. But a doctor ended Beam’s treatment after about 30 minutes, after which Wilson pushed him back to his cell. Within days, Beam died.
A medical examiner’s report found Beam’s death was caused by pneumonia, but Dr Susi Vassallo, an emergency medicine physician and medical toxicologist who has served as an expert witness in several cases involving heat in US prisons, testified that she believed long-term exposure to extreme heat contributed to his death, as well as the deaths of three other prisoners at the Dade correctional institute. Vassallo said that in no other case that she has participated in has there been such extensive heat data inside the prison. “It’s rather shocking, honestly,” she said of the temperatures and humidity levels captured by the sensors. “These are dangerous heat indices, putting these individuals at substantial risk of serious harm.”
Defense arguments and trial continuation
During their cross-examination of expert witnesses, attorneys for the Dade correctional institute argued that more than 100 ceiling and exhaust fans throughout the facility helped mitigate heat in the prison and that the eighth amendment prohibiting “cruel and unusual punishments” was not relevant. “In 1791, when the eighth amendment was ratified, there was no air conditioning,” said Mathew Gutierrez, defense counsel for the Florida department of corrections, FDC secretary Ricky Dixon and Dade correctional institution warden Francisco Acosta, in his opening statement on Monday. “So the lack of air conditioning could not have been encompassed in the eighth amendment.” Attorneys for the defendants also said that prisoners were permitted to wear shorts and had access to water jugs with ice during the summers. But prisoners said ice in the orange water coolers quickly melted because they were filled with hot water from the showers. Vassallo said that when temperatures reach a certain point, fans aren’t helpful, and they can actually increase body temperature.
Wilson has burn scars on much of his body from an incident in an Indiana jail when another inmate poured chemicals on the person in the bunk above his. On the areas of his body with chemical burns, he is unable to sweat. Wilson said he often gets itchy heat rashes when it’s hot in the prison. “When I move around, I can get scabbed up,” he said. “Then, with the rash that is on my body, it’s like it’s irritating to the point where it’s like burning.”
The trial is expected to resume next Monday, when more prisoners will testify about their experiences with heat at the Dade correctional institution, which can hold up to 1,500 people. Later, the prison and the Florida department of corrections will present their case.