Blood found on a knife that Dwain Hall sent to a friend matched the DNA profile of British woman Sonia Exelby, a US court has heard. Hall, 54, is on trial in Florida over the kidnap and murder of Exelby, 32, who had struggled with mental illness throughout her life.
Messages before the discovery
The trial was shown a series of Facebook messages exchanged between Hall and Rick Snyder last October, before Exelby's body was found in a shallow grave. In the exchanges, Hall asks Snyder for his address in Ohio and refuses to go into detail, saying "can't tell you here. Lease (sic) I say the better", and indicated his phone "may be tapped".
In a further message he said: "Might be a big storm coming for me". He then sent a picture of a UPS label showing he had sent a parcel to Snyder. Hall wrote that he would need the contents back in six months "if this storm passes over with no lingering fallout".
Package contents and DNA evidence
Following the discovery of the messages on Hall's phone and the UPS label, investigators travelled to Washington county in Ohio, where local detectives executed a search warrant at Snyder's property on November 4, 2025. The package was found inside a cloth bag in the dresser of Snyder's bedroom, the court heard.
It included a knife in a sheath and a bracelet that belonged to Hall. A crime laboratory biologist said both Hall and Exelby were "possible contributors" to a mixed DNA profile found on the bracelet. Hall, Exelby and Snyder were also found to be "possible contributors" to DNA found on the knife sheath.
The jury was shown a picture of the black knife, which had "Dorkworf pointy end goes in the other guy" printed in capitals on the blade. The biologist said she had removed the handle of the knife and found "reddish brown staining that did give chemical indications for the presence of blood".
Prosecution case and background
The biologist said Hall was "excluded as the source" of the DNA and told the court: "The DNA profile matched the DNA profile from Sonia Exelby." The jury had previously heard from prosecutors that Hall was a predator who had manipulated his victim and then stabbed her to death "for his own sadistic pleasure".
Exelby, from Southsea, Portsmouth, was reported missing from her home on October 12 last year, by which time police established she had left the country. Her body was found by US investigators in Marion County, Florida, on October 17. She had been stabbed four times in the left side, with wounds up to seven inches deep.
Hall was traced by police through the attempted use of Exelby's credit card by the roadside assistance company he owned. He is currently on trial in Ocala for her kidnap and murder.