Baby Reindeer's Fiona Harvey in court over antisemitic voicemails
Baby Reindeer's Fiona Harvey in court over antisemitic claims

Fiona Harvey, the Scottish woman who claims to have inspired the obsessive stalker character in Netflix's Baby Reindeer, is facing a criminal trial over allegations of racially aggravated harassment.

Harvey, 61, is accused of sending several emails and three voicemails containing antisemitic material to lawyer Mark Lewis between September 4 and October 9, 2025. The case was heard at Highbury Corner Magistrates' Court on Thursday, where it emerged that Lewis initially believed Harvey was a potential client.

Court Appearance and Next Steps

Harvey, of Camden, north London, did not enter a plea but elected to have the case heard at Crown Court. She is due to appear at Harrow Crown Court on December 17 for a pre-trial preparation hearing. The charge of racially aggravated harassment without violence is an either-way offence, meaning it can be dealt with at either a magistrates' court or Crown Court.

The latest legal battle comes as Harvey prepares for her own lawsuit against Netflix, which made Baby Reindeer, written by Scots comedian Richard Gadd. Harvey launched a £128 million lawsuit against the streaming giant in June 2024, claiming she was falsely portrayed as a convicted stalker and that the series wrecked her life. She alleges Netflix told "brutal lies" about her to more than 50 million viewers around the world.

US Trial Date Set

A US judge has now ruled that the defamation and emotional distress claims will be heard by a jury on May 18, 2027, at the US District Court for the Central District of California. Harvey's lawyer Richard Roth previously said his client was "elated" after the trial date was confirmed, adding that the case had been sitting for too long.

He said: "We've just learned that the trial of Fiona Harvey versus Netflix is going to be on May 18, 2027. We just got the notice, like within the last hour. Both sides submitted a document which provided for more time, but the judge said, 'No, you're trying this in May.' I'm excited about this case. I think this case has been sitting for too long."

Netflix's Response and Series Impact

Harvey claims Baby Reindeer falsely presented her as a convicted stalker, despite her never having been convicted of the offence. The series opens with the statement "This is a true story" and depicts Martha, played by Jessica Gunning, sexually assaulting Gadd's character, attacking him with a glass and waiting outside his home for hours.

Netflix has denied the allegations and said the events depicted in the series were substantially true. The company has vowed to defend the case vigorously, while Gadd has previously insisted that the character Martha Scott is not Fiona Harvey.

The series, which was adapted from Gadd's 2019 Edinburgh Fringe show, became a global sensation after arriving on Netflix in April 2024. It has been watched by around 100 million people worldwide and scooped six Emmy Awards, including honours for Gadd and Gunning.

Within days of its release, online viewers began attempting to identify the real people behind the characters. Harvey went public in the Daily Record in April 2024 to claim she was the woman who inspired Martha.