Mauchline holiday let plan backed despite 13 neighbour objections
Mauchline holiday let plan backed despite objections

Plans to convert a large Mauchline house into holiday accommodation for up to ten guests have been recommended for approval despite objections from neighbouring residents over noise, privacy and fears of parties.

Ayrshire Property Options Ltd has applied to change the use of Abbey House, on Sorn Road, from a residential property into a five-bedroom short-term holiday let. The proposals also include an outdoor hot tub and a raised decking area intended for dining and socialising.

Neighbours raise concerns

The application has attracted 13 objections, all from residents living on streets immediately adjoining the property. Objectors have raised concerns about noise from guests using the outdoor areas, increased traffic and parking pressures, and the potential for overlooking neighbouring gardens.

Some have also questioned whether the property could be used to host weddings or other events, and whether sufficient management arrangements would be in place to deal with complaints.

Officers back the scheme

However, East Ayrshire Council planning officers have concluded that the proposed use would not have an unacceptable impact on neighbouring properties. Their report acknowledges that holidaymakers could cause more disturbance than permanent residents because of the frequent turnover of guests and the potential for increased outdoor activity.

Nevertheless, officers consider that the size of the property, its extensive grounds and existing boundary screening would help limit the impact. They have recommended additional landscaping and boundary treatments to address concerns about privacy, particularly near the proposed raised decking.

Next steps

The applicant has submitted an operating plan containing house rules and a complaints procedure, while the council’s Environmental Health Service and Ayrshire Roads Alliance have raised no objections. Officers also consider that visitors staying at the property could benefit Mauchline’s local economy by using nearby shops, cafés and other businesses.

Nine letters of support were submitted by the applicant, although none were received through the council’s formal public consultation process. Planning permission has been recommended for approval, subject to conditions, when the application goes before councillors on Friday, November 20.