The director of a family-run holiday letting business in Devon has criticised Prime Minister Andy Burnham's plans for a tourist tax, warning it could have a serious impact on the local economy.
Under the proposed legislation, some regional authorities would be able to introduce a levy on visitors' stays across the country. The Devon and Torbay Combined County Authority is believed to have the power under the plans.
Business concerns over tourist tax
Alex Gwillim, 31, is the director of Sweetcombe Cottage Holidays in Sidmouth, Devon, an independent, family-run holiday letting agency that has operated in the east of Devon for 40 years. The company represents more than 160 holiday properties in the area and works with more than 100 housekeepers and tradespeople.
Ms Gwillim said: "Having been involved in industry discussions over the past year, I have serious concerns about the impact a tourist tax could have on our local economy."
She added: "I think it's important to clarify that this is not simply a tax on overseas tourists. It could affect British people staying in paid accommodation within their own country, whether for a family holiday, visiting friends and relatives, attending weddings or funerals, school or scout trips, or travelling for business, subject to any exemptions ultimately agreed."
Impact on domestic tourism and affordability
Ms Gwillim believes the tax would discourage domestic tourism at a time when the area should be encouraging more visitors and promoting sustainable travel closer to home.
She said: "East Devon is not suffering from overtourism. Visitor spending has not fully recovered, and we should be encouraging more visitors, particularly outside the summer season. Affordability is already a significant concern."
A 5% levy, which local leaders have suggested would be the maximum rate, would mean an additional £50 on a £1,000 holiday, without any additional income for the accommodation provider, Ms Gwillim said.
She added: "With rising operating costs and inflation, businesses already face difficult decisions about increasing prices. An additional levy would further limit our ability to make necessary price adjustments without making holidays unaffordable."
Concerns over local spending and administration
The director also fears visitors could spend less locally or choose to holiday elsewhere.
Ms Gwillim said: "This is not necessarily new money entering our local economy. It could simply divert existing visitor spending away from our cafés, restaurants, pubs, shops and attractions, or discourage visitors from coming altogether.
"Our industry has also faced considerable regulatory changes in recent years. Another tax would bring further administrative burdens, particularly for small independent businesses without systems in place to collect it."
She added: "What tangible benefits would East Devon see? Without guaranteed ring-fencing or transparent distribution of revenue, how can we be confident that money collected from visitors staying in Sidmouth, Budleigh or Beer would benefit those communities?"
Council warning on economic risks
Devon County Council said in May that the introduction of a tourist tax in the county "would place at risk an industry worth over £1.6billion annually and supporting more than 50,000 jobs, with disproportionate impacts on coastal and rural communities where alternative employment opportunities are limited".
It added: "Such a policy would not simply affect visitors, but would directly impact Devon residents through reduced hours, job losses, and declining income for local businesses.
"In areas such as Torbay, the South Hams, and East Devon towns including Sidmouth, Exmouth and Honiton, even a modest reduction in visitor numbers would have immediate and damaging economic consequences. At a time when households are facing ongoing cost-of-living pressures, and when UK tourism already faces a relatively high tax burden, it is counterproductive to introduce further costs that risk driving visitors overseas."
"Devon should take a clear and principled position in defence of its residents, its businesses and its economic future."