Some leaseholders could face higher costs to extend their leases under the government's proposed reforms, despite promises to make the process cheaper and easier, an expert has warned.
The warning follows the government's announcement of plans to overhaul leasehold ownership in England and Wales. The Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill will enter Parliament on 19 November, proposing a £250 annual ground rent cap, the abolition of marriage value, and cheaper 990-year lease extensions.
Uncertainty over savings
Linz Darlington, managing director of lease extension specialists Homehold, says ministers have left a crucial question unanswered: how much will homeowners actually save?
Ministers intend to set the valuation rates that determine lease extension costs through secondary legislation. Until then, uncertainty remains. Homeowners with 80 years or fewer remaining on their leases should benefit from the abolition of marriage value, and those paying high ground rents could also see costs fall. However, Darlington warns that homeowners with longer leases could face higher premiums.
“Crucially, though, the Bill will not set the underlying percentage rates that set the price of lease extensions. Those figures are being left to secondary legislation, meaning we still don’t know how much leaseholders will save, or whether people with more than 80 years remaining could even end up paying more,” Darlington said.
Missing safeguards questioned
The Bill aims to address outstanding problems with the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024, several major provisions of which have yet to take effect. Darlington questioned why ministers have not included safeguards to ensure cheaper lease extensions, noting that housing minister Matthew Pennycook proposed similar protections while in opposition, but the previous Conservative government rejected them.
Darlington also challenged Pennycook's reported claim that ministers cannot now include those safeguards. “Despite commanding a 167-seat majority, Pennycook told BBC Breakfast last week that those safeguards cannot be written into the legislation now. That comment simply doesn’t stack up when he is already using this very Bill to amend other parts of the 2024 legislation.”
Potential delays beyond 2028
Darlington warned that homeowners may face a lengthy wait for the changes. The Bill must pass through Parliament, and ministers must establish the valuation rates through secondary legislation.
“The Bill is just starting its parliamentary journey. Other housing bills have taken 12 months or more to make it through the process, suggesting it is unlikely to be implemented until 2028 at the earliest,” he said. “Considering the complexity of the legislation, and the fact there are ongoing legal challenges from freeholders due to be heard in the Court of Appeal next year, it could still be a lot later than that.”
The government plans to introduce the £250 annual ground rent cap in 2028, subject to parliamentary approval. However, ministers have yet to confirm when the new lease extension valuation rules will take effect.
Impact on estate agents
The uncertainty could complicate leasehold sales, particularly those involving properties with shorter leases. Some buyers and sellers may delay lease extensions in anticipation of lower premiums, but waiting carries risks. Lease terms continue to shorten, while mortgage lenders still apply their existing requirements.
The reforms promise cheaper extensions for many homeowners, but not everyone will necessarily benefit. Until ministers publish the valuation rates and confirm a timetable, the true financial impact remains unclear.