Isabelle Williams, 24, from Newcastle Emlyn, has been left facing thousands of pounds worth of repairs after discovering her first home, which she rented out, covered in dog faeces, urine and waste. She described the discovery as "soul destroying" after visiting the property on November 17 and finding it in a shocking state.
The property, which she bought when she was 19, had been transformed into a home through years of hard work and renovations she carried out herself. After deciding to rent it out, Isabelle was horrified to discover it like "a dog kennel", with moulding faeces covering the sofas and floors, dirty dishes piled up in the sink and food left rotting in the fridge.
She now faces the prospect of stripping the property back and carrying out a full renovation before it can become liveable again.
Emotional attachment to first home
Speaking to WalesOnline, Isabelle said the experience had been particularly difficult because of the emotional attachment she had to the house.
"I purchased it when I was 19, which was about five years ago now," she said. "I lived there for a few years, it was my first home after moving out from my parents'. I made it a home. I'm a carpenter and tiler by trade, and I renovated it all myself. I was really proud of it."
After buying a second property with her boyfriend, Isabelle decided to rent out her first home as she looked to build her property portfolio from a young age. "I'm very independent, I have my own business and then I wanted to start young and renovate and rent out," she explained.
Tenant provided references and paid upfront
Her first experience as a landlord had been positive, with her initial tenant proving to be "lovely". However, when he eventually moved on, her second experience would be very different.
Isabelle said she had taken the necessary precautions before agreeing to rent the property, with the tenant providing references and paying his rent and deposit upfront. "He had good references and everything was done properly. I had no reason to think that there was anything wrong. Everything was done prim and proper," she said.
The tenant moved into the property at the end of August and initially appeared to be settling in well. Isabelle had planned to carry out an inspection after the first month but decided to give him some additional time to make the property his home.
"He moved in at the end of August, and he paid the rent and the bond upfront with no questions asked. So he paid them immediately," she said. "And then he was in there for a month.... Normally, we do a month inspection after they first move in, but I said, 'I'll give you two months to settle in and just make it your home now.'"
Tenant stopped paying rent and moved out
However, when the next rent payment became due at the end of September, the tenant told her he was having difficulties getting money into his bank account. Isabelle said she was initially understanding of his circumstances and was happy to give him some time to resolve the issue.
"The first month came to pay his second month's rent - so at the end of September - and he said he was having trouble getting money in the bank," she recalled. "I have always been an understanding person. Everyone has financial difficulties and that is absolutely fine, so I said, 'No worries, just keep in contact.' But as the weeks were going on, there was no contact whatsoever."
As the weeks passed without communication, Isabelle became increasingly concerned and eventually considered getting solicitors involved. Then, in November, the tenant finally got in touch to tell her he was moving out.
"I got to the point where I was going to get solicitors involved but then he happened to contact me and said, 'I've posted the keys through the door, and I'm moving out'," she said.
Property left in shocking state
On November 17, Isabelle travelled to the property to see what condition it had been left in. She said she was immediately concerned to discover the door had been left unlocked, but what awaited her inside was far worse than she could have imagined.
"I went down there and he left the door unlocked, which was just mad," she said. "I went in and it was after five, so it was dark, and I went in on my own. I wasn't sure what I was expecting when I walked - it gives me shivers now."
Isabelle had specifically included a clause in the tenancy agreement stating that pets were not allowed, however she was horrified to discover evidence of a dog living in the property. "I've always taken advice from people to put on the contract: 'No pets allowed'," she said. "That was clear in bold on the contract, but the tenant went against that and brought a dog in, that I was not even made aware of."
The first thing Isabelle noticed when she walked through the door was the overwhelming smell of dog faeces. "When I smelt the dog mess and saw all the poo covering the sofa, the floors, a dog cage, a part of me thought - am I going to see a dead puppy? Am I going to see an unconscious person? I didn't know what I was expecting when I walked in, it was really scary."
Footage captured inside the property shows the extent of the mess, with dog faeces covering the sofas and floors, while human hair had been left in the sink and the toilets had not been flushed. The kitchen was also left in a filthy condition, with dirty dishes piled up and food still inside the fridge.
Isabelle said the smell was particularly pungent and suggested the property had been left abandoned for some time. "The smell was strong and it was quite mouldy in there, as if he'd put bins out, but he left them inside for weeks," she alleged. "He'd clearly abandoned it because there was milk in the fridge that was dated back to the 15th of September, so he must've just left the place and not bothered to get in contact."
Describing the condition of the house, she added: "It was like he used it as his dog kennels - for his dogs to just run wild."
Full renovation required
But beyond the mess and the financial implications, Isabelle said it was the destruction of somewhere she had once been so proud of that hurt the most. She recalled the memories of moving into the property, renovating it and making it exactly how she wanted it.
"You remember moving in and renovating it, painting it, putting in the new kitchen and new flooring, and being just how you want it," she said. "Then you get it up to spec, ready for someone else to go in, and weirdly it's like giving away your child. I trusted the wrong person. It's disheartening to see what once was my little warm Welsh cottage is now a dumping ground, really."
The house remains in much the same condition, with Isabelle preparing to begin the clean-up operation while also juggling her full-time job. She said all of the furniture inside belongs to her and will have to be thrown away, as she cannot face the thought of anyone else using it after what has happened.
"All of the furniture is mine - I left it all furnished. It's all going to go," Isabelle said. "The thought of letting somebody else go in and sit on a sofa that's had dog poo on it, or use it... no. It's all going to come out and it's going to have a full renovation."
Dog urine has also reportedly soaked into the walls and flooring, meaning the floors will need to be removed and replaced. Isabelle said she was worried about what might be uncovered once the work begins, with the final repair bill still unknown.
"There's dog pee up the walls, and all over the floor, so that will have to be lifted and have to have a new floor. It's definitely a lot of financial loss. I am starting from scratch basically," she said. "The fact that it was my first home... it definitely makes you feel really sick inside that someone can do that. But the financial part of it is still to come."
She admitted she was particularly anxious about the possibility of discovering further damage beneath the mess. "It's scary - once you take it all out, what are you uncovering? There's heaps of mess and you don't know what's underneath or what's behind it, so it's kind of like, where do you stop? Where is it going to end before you're racking up a big bill like thousands of pounds?" she said. "It's fresh - yesterday to be exact - so, how much it's going to cost... I don't know. I don't want to think about it right now, it's really, really scary."
Support from family and local businesses
Despite the ordeal, Isabelle said she had been overwhelmed by the support she had received from family, friends and local businesses who have offered to help get the property back into shape. She said she was fortunate to have a large family network willing to help with the renovation, while cleaning companies had also reached out with offers of assistance.
"People have been so kind. I have a big family network that's going to help me turn it around, but there's been cleaning companies out there that have messaged and said, you know, 'We're willing to help'," she said. "Everyone's come together, and it's just so nice - it's quite emotional, actually."
As a carpenter and tiler, Isabelle is also able to carry out much of the work herself alongside her boyfriend, something she recognises not every landlord would be in a position to do. "Obviously, I am fortunate in the sense that there's other landlords out there that go through it and they aren't good with renovating and they have to get tradies in," she said. "But I am lucky that I can just do it with my boyfriend; we can do it together."
Lesson learned for future
Although the experience has been a painful introduction to being a landlord, Isabelle said it had not put her off her ambitions to buy, renovate and rent out properties. Instead, she said she had learned an important lesson about the challenges of managing a rental property and admitted she would approach things differently in future.
"I am taking this as an early life lesson. It hasn't scared me off renting out, you know? That was always my plan: renovate and rent out," she said. "But I think for future reference, I'm not going to be my own landlord; I'll do it through an estate agent."
Isabelle also hopes her experience will give people a better understanding of the realities of being a landlord, particularly the financial risks involved. "A lot of people are like, 'Oh my god, look at you, you know, you're a landlord' and this, that, and the other. But it's not as pretty as it seems, and it takes years and years and years for it to become a financial profit - years to break even. Currently it's just a loss... It's not all what it's painted to be."
And despite the heartbreak of seeing the home she worked so hard to create left in such a condition, Isabelle hopes speaking out could help other landlords avoid a similar experience. "Hopefully my experience can help someone else not make the same mistakes," she said.