More than 250 savings accounts now pay 5% or more, up from just one a year ago, according to Moneyfactscompare.co.uk. The top one-year fixed rate pays 5.21% and the best easy access account 4.89%, as CPI inflation rose to 3.6% in October. Savers on the average new savings rate of 3.85% are just £25 better off on £10,000 after inflation over a year, while those earning 2% lose £160 in real terms annually. Inflation is forecast to peak at 4.4% in 2027.
Higher interest rates could also bring a tax bill, as someone with £20,000 earning £1,000 in interest could pay around £220 under the new 44% savings income tax rate from April 2027. An expert told Newspage that savers should ditch poorly performing accounts and switch to better deals, warning: "If your account pays below inflation, switch now."
Experts weigh in on rate environment
Rob Mansfield, Independent Financial Advisor at Tonbridge-based Rootes Wealth Management, said: "For short-term money these rates could be attractive, but if it's an emergency fund, check whether you can access the money if you needed it. It's always worth considering inflation, as it sets a bar your growth has to achieve just to stand still."
"At 3.6%, inflation is going to eat into the returns. If this is long-term savings, it's worth considering whether investments are a better fit than cash."
Tax implications and the 'real question'
Nouran Moustafa, practice principal and IFA at Roxton Wealth, said: "More than 250 savings accounts paying 5% sounds fantastic, but the real question is how much of that interest savers actually get to keep. With inflation at 3.6% and savings tax rising from April, a headline rate doesn't tell the whole story."
"I'd consider fixing a portion of savings at 5% or more if the money won't be needed for a year. But emergency funds belong in easy-access accounts. Nobody knows how long these deals will last."
"Banks can withdraw competitive offers quickly, while variable rates can change. And here's the uncomfortable part: from April 2027, higher-rate taxpayers will pay 44% tax on savings interest above their £500 Personal Savings Allowance."
"A cash ISA could therefore be worth more than a taxable account offering a higher headline rate. My message? Stop chasing interest rates in isolation. The number that matters is what your money earns after inflation and tax."
Locking in rates and the case for diversification
Scott Gallacher, director of Leicester-based Rowley Turton, said: "With one-year fixed rates now above 5% and inflation at 3.6%, there's a good argument for savers locking in at least some of their money, particularly if they don't expect to need it over the next 12 months. However, I wouldn't rush to fix everything."
"Easy access rates aren't far behind and having access to your money is important. While a 5% savings rate looks attractive, with inflation at 3.6%, the real return is fairly modest, particularly once tax is taken into account."
"And the proposed increase in savings income tax to 44% for higher-rate taxpayers makes matters worse. Someone paying 44% tax on their interest would keep just 2.8% from a 5% savings account, actually losing purchasing power at the moment."
"For me, cash is about security and meeting shorter-term needs. For money you won't need for five or 10 years, provided you can live with some investment risk, I'd be looking beyond savings accounts rather than simply chasing the highest interest rate."
Philly Ponniah, Chartered Wealth Manager and financial coach at Philly Financial, said: "Cash should only hold money you need in the short term: an emergency fund and anything you'll spend in the next few years. Keep some in easy access and fix what you won't touch."
"Top deals rarely last long, so if your account pays below inflation, switch now. Even 5% may not be enough. For higher-rate taxpayers, from April 2027 a 5% rate could be worth just 2.8% after tax on interest above their allowance, which is below today's inflation."
"Use your cash ISA allowance first. Beyond that, cash keeps you level at best. If you have the tolerance for some risk, invest the rest for the long term, ideally in a stocks and shares ISA. Cash protects you from short-term ups and downs, but over time inflation is the bigger risk, and investing is how you potentially get ahead of it."
Graham Nicoll, financial planner and Chartered FCSI at NCL Wealth Partners, said: "A 5% savings rate might grab the headlines, but inflation and tax can quietly steal the party. Cash is king for emergency funds and short-term needs, but a poor long-term wealth creator."
"Fixing can lock in today's attractive rates, while easy access provides flexibility. Don't expect 5% deals to hang around forever. If your savings rate is below inflation, your money is going backwards in real terms."
"Loyalty to a poorly paying bank is an expensive habit. Higher savings taxes will only sharpen the squeeze, making Cash ISAs increasingly valuable."
"For money you won't need for five years or more, diversified investments offer the potential for stronger long-term returns, albeit with greater risk. The real question isn't who's paying the highest rate today, but whether your money is working hard enough to fund the life you want tomorrow."
Remember the tax element
Harvey Dhillon, founder and CEO of Zmartly, said: "The tax side is what most savers will miss. From April 6, 2027, the savings income tax rates rise to 24 per cent for basic rate, 44 per cent for higher rate and 49 per cent for additional rate taxpayers."
"At 5 per cent, interest builds up quickly and plenty of people who have never paid tax on their savings will find they now owe it, often through a tax code change they did not expect. Before you fix, check where the interest will land."
"A cash ISA keeps it out of tax altogether, so use your ISA allowance first, then hold any other cash in the name of whichever partner pays the lower rate. On a long fix, check when the interest is paid, because a lump sum at the end can push you into a higher band in that year.
If your account pays below inflation, move it. Loyalty is the most expensive habit a saver can have."
Antonia Medlicott, founder and managing director of London-based Investing Insiders, said: "Don't let a 5% headline rush you. For many savers, especially higher-rate taxpayers, even today's best one-year fix still loses money in real terms."
"A one-year bond opened now usually pays interest in late 2027, just as tax on savings rises to 44% for higher-rate taxpayers. On £20,000 at 5.21%, they'd keep around 4% after tax, while the Bank of England expects inflation to reach about 5% by mid-2027."
"The real scandal is the millions still earning around 1% with big banks. If your rate starts with a '1', move it today. Keep emergency money in top easy access and fix the rest in stages."
"These deals will last months, not years, and banks cut savings rates far faster than they raise them. Use your cash ISA first. The £20,000 allowance survived the Budget and is worth more as savings tax rises. Couples should check whether the lower earner should hold more of the cash."
Not just about headline rate
Paul Denley, CEO of London-based Oakham Wealth Management, said: "The return of 5% savings rates is welcome, but savers should also consider on what they earn after tax and inflation, rather than the headline rate. With inflation proving stubborn, attractive headline savings rates could be around for some time."
"It makes sense to lock in a competitive fixed rate on money you won't need over the next year, while retaining sufficient cash in easy access accounts. Inertia is the enemy of savers."
"Leaving money in an uncompetitive account is effectively accepting a gradual erosion of your wealth. Higher savings taxes make using ISA allowances increasingly important."
"Higher rate taxpayers may also want to consider short-dated, low-coupon government bonds, where capital gains are tax-free. For those looking to consistently beat inflation over the longer term, rather than simply preserve cash, a diversified investment portfolio is worth considering."