State pension £3,000 gap explained as DWP confirms £1,086.36 rise
State pension £3,000 gap explained as DWP rise confirmed

About 8 million people, or 60% of pensioners, receive the old state pension and face a £3,000 annual gap compared with those on the new state pension, a difference that widens every April. The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) last week released details showing exactly how much state pensions will rise next year.

People on the full new state pension will receive £250.70 a week, amounting to £13,036.40 over 12 months. By contrast, those on the old state pension get the Category A or B basic pension of £192.10, up from £184.90, or £9,989.20 a year. The old state pension can be topped up in several ways people paid into while working, although millions just get the basic rate.

Moneybox highlights widening gap

Radio 4's Moneybox show examined the issue, with presenter Paul Lewis explaining it can lead to a huge gap: "State pensions will go up in April and politicians often say sometimes with some pride it will just be over £250 a week - more than £13,000 a year. But that's only half the picture, in fact less than half because most pensioners don't get that pension. It's the new state pension paid to younger people who are now in their early 70s. Older pensioners get the old state pension which will increase to only around £192 a week - that's less than £10,000 a year."

Lewis added: "And that gap between the two of about £3,000 grows every April because when they both rise by the same percentage, the bigger your pension, the bigger your increase in pounds per week."

Listeners share their experiences

One 76-year-old listener said he gets £184.90 a week in state pension. Lewis quoted him as saying: "Why am I discriminated against and not able to receive the new basic pension just because I was born 9 months earlier than the particular date that they decided. It makes me worse off financially and I'm feeling aggrieved that friends and people I know who are just nine months younger should be awarded, £56 more a week than me."

Another listener, Marilyn from South Wales, retired in 2008 on the old state pension. She said every four weeks she gets a total of £1,016, including graduated pension benefits and additional pension because she paid into SERPS. "My husband's on the new state pension but he's got a private pension. What is the difference between the old state pension and the new one? I've got no idea. It seems like people on the old pension are not talked about any more," she said.

Why the cliff edge exists

Daniela Silcock, who runs The Pension Research Consultancy, explained the transition: "They tried to make the system fairer. They've tried to give a higher basic amount and phased out and gotten rid of the earnings related pension. So some people got pensions through SERPS or S2P or Graduated Retirement Benefit which means on top of the basic rate they also got an earnings related pension to replace what they might have got from an employer."

Silcock continued: "Now the government says everybody should be saving through their employer so we're going to use the state pension to give you a basic rate to make sure yu have enough to live on and meet your basic needs. But as a result they had this cliff edge where they moved from the old system to the new system in 2016." She added: "They could have given the new state pension to everyone but that would have cost £10 billion a year more. It is unfair, it has to be unfair because it's not affordable to make that change for everyone."

Lewis noted that about 3 million people on the old state pension get more than the new state pension because of the additional rates they paid into. Silcock also said some people on the old state pension might not be getting all they're entitled to: "There's lots of benefits for women who were married, and paid married woman's stamp who maybe were carers who reached the age of 80 or were widowed or bereaved. There have been under-payments. If you think you may have been under-paid because you fit into these categories you can contact the pensions service by looking online."