Quality Street tub offers best value in £4.50 chocolate count test
Quality Street wins £4.50 chocolate tub value test

A £4.50 tub of Quality Street offered the best value for money in a comparison of three popular Christmas chocolate tins, holding the highest number of chocolates and the widest selection.

The Mirror's Mia O'Hare bought Quality Street, Celebrations and Heroes tubs from Sainsbury's, each priced at £4.50, and counted the contents to see which gave the most for the money. The test also checked whether Bounty bars really are the most common chocolate in Celebrations.

Heroes holds the fewest chocolates

The Cadbury Heroes tin weighed 475g, making it the lightest of the three, and contained the smallest quantity of chocolate. The tub held 50 chocolates in total.

The assortment was fairly balanced, with only two chocolate varieties not having six pieces each. Crunchie Bits numbered six, while Dairy Milk Caramel had five.

Celebrations contains more than stated

A Celebrations tub is often the source of family debate over who gets which chocolate. Although many people try to avoid being left with Bounty bars at the bottom, these are not actually the most abundant sweet in the tin.

The 500g tub is meant to include 51 chocolate bars, though this particular one contained 54 in total. Milky Way was the chocolate that appeared most often in the Celebrations tub.

Quality Street comes out on top

Quality Street emerged as the best-value option, offering both the highest chocolate count and the greatest selection. However, distribution varied between flavours, with just five Green Triangles present.

In total, the 550g tub held 60 chocolates, the most of the three tins tested.