A 59p tin of tomato soup has been named the best in the UK, outperforming household brands Heinz and Baxters in a blind taste test conducted by consumer champion Which?.
The winning supermarket own-label soups cost a fraction of the price of market leader Heinz, which charges £1.70 for a 400g tin. The priciest soup tested, Baxters at £2.05, finished bottom of the rankings.
Which? panel verdict
Which? gathered a panel of 77 soup lovers to sample 12 tinned tomato soups. The testers evaluated each soup on overall flavour, texture, appearance, aroma, sweetness, tanginess, thickness and creaminess. The tasting was carried out blind, meaning testers were not told whether they were trying Heinz, Baxters or a cheaper supermarket option, and they were banned from discussing their opinions to prevent swaying other testers.
Baxters Cream of Tomato Soup scored 58%, with most tasters deeming the flavour too weak and the texture lacking sufficient thickness. Waitrose Essential Cream of Tomato Soup scored 66%, with Which? noting "it lost marks for flavour, and around half thought it wasn't thick or creamy enough".
Branded contenders
Heinz Cream of Tomato Soup scored 68%, with Which? reporting "more than a third thought the flavour was too weak and not sweet enough, while 62% said it wasn't creamy enough". Crosse and Blackwell Cream of Tomato Soup scored 76%, the highest-rated brand tested, though at £1.25 it still costs roughly twice the price of most supermarket own labels.
Lidl Newgate Cream of Tomato Soup scored 70%, with testers saying it "looked the part" but "the flavour and texture fell slightly short". Aldi Bramwells Cream of Tomato Soup scored 71%, and Morrisons Cream of Tomato Soup scored 72%, described as "a decent option".
Top-scoring tins
Marks and Spencer Cream of Tomato Soup and Co-op Classic Cream of Tomato Soup both scored 73%. Asda Cream of Tomato Soup secured third place overall with 77% and was awarded "Best Buy" status, scoring highly for appearance, aroma, flavour and texture.
Tesco Cream of Tomato Soup and Sainsbury's Cream of Tomato Soup tied for top spot with 78% each. Testers noted Tesco's soup "excelled on every measure, with just the right strength of flavour and tang for the majority of tasters". Of Sainsbury's, Which? said: "Most tasters found the balance of tanginess and sweetness just right. It also won over tasters on appearance and texture, with three quarters rating it the perfect creaminess. It also outstanding value at just 59p a tin."