Chief sportswriter Keith Jackson has said it would be ethically and professionally wrong for the Scottish Football Association to sack head coach Sebastien Pocognoli now, despite a difficult start to his tenure.
Jackson wrote that the axe will not come down on the Belgian for the time being, and nor should it, despite angry calls for his removal. He said Pocognoli will have to dust himself down over the next five months after a tumultuous first campaign as successor to Steve Clarke.
Backing the appointment
Jackson said the idea that someone inside Hampden's sixth floor may relieve Pocognoli of his responsibilities before then is "for the birds." He argued that chief executive Ian Maxwell, who sanctioned the manager's appointment amid a flurry of jargon about data and metrics, will have to ride this one out until March, hoping that the AI and the algorithms might yet be proven right.
Jackson said this is the hand that Maxwell and chief football officer Craig Mulholland have dealt themselves, and they must stick with it and show they have the courage of their convictions. He noted that Pocognoli may not have covered himself in glory during his first six games in charge, but having been given the remit to make fundamental changes to Scotland's top team squad, he deserves support and breathing space to reflect on how it started and where it's going.
Early warning signs
Jackson said the initial signs should have set early warning alarm bells clattering inside the SFA's bunker, because the first six games of the post-Clarke era suggest the national side is in danger of regressing rather than moving forward. In six Nations League games, 10 goals have been conceded by the new three-at-the-back formation, while only five goals have been scored, despite the project being centered around creating a front-footed, aggressive, attacking approach.
Jackson said Pocognoli will argue, with genuine justification, that the sort of change he has been headhunted to oversee requires time, patience, and hard work. He added that Pocognoli would be within his rights to demand that his superiors hold their nerve while he gets on with the heavy lifting.
Data-driven decision
Jackson said that in their combined wisdom, and with the assistance of chat GBT, Mulholland, Maxwell, and president Mike Mulraney decided that Pocognoli was the best qualified for the job, despite his complete inexperience of managing in the international field. He quoted Mulholland as saying, "The data actually told us the most successful international managers are those who are doing the job for the first time."
Jackson said Mulholland had better hope the computer was right, or this statement could end up haunting him and the men who hired him. He concluded that Pocognoli deserves the chance to prove it when the next campaign gets up and running, but all those involved must be man enough to own the outcome if things should take a turn for the worse.