Gary Neville questioned Mauricio Pochettino's decision to recall Matthijs de Ligt after the defender's blunder allowed Liverpool to take an early lead against Manchester United at Anfield.
In the tenth minute, a hopeful pass over the top from Liverpool full-back Ronald Araujo caused chaos in United's half, with De Ligt letting the ball run through to Alexander Isak. The striker raced in behind in acres of space, and moments later Leny Yoro clattered into the back of him on the edge of the penalty area.
Referee Samuel Barrott showed Yoro a straight red card for the clumsy foul, reducing United to ten men in a nightmare start to Pochettino's reign as manager. Dominik Szoboszlai then superbly struck the resulting free-kick beyond Senne Lammes to break the deadlock. Florian Wirtz doubled the hosts' advantage inside 13 minutes, directing home Rio Ngumoha's cross with an audacious flicked finish.
Neville's criticism of De Ligt and Yoro
Watching replays of the errors that led to Liverpool's opener, the former United full-back revealed his reaction to De Ligt's selection. 'When I saw Matthijs de Ligt's name on the teamsheet, I have to be honest with you, I was absolutely stunned,' Neville said on Sky Sports' commentary of the match.
'The reason I was stunned was because of this: if you watched him against Como four weeks ago, he was very much well of it. That is just a basic ball over the top of him. It's his problem to start with.'
Though De Ligt was the main focus of Neville's criticism, Yoro did not escape without receiving an attack of his own. 'Leny Yoro can be further across but if you look at De Ligt in this channel, he's miles away from him,' Neville added. 'Yoro should be across, yes, he can get further around. He has to cover and he doesn't. He reacts late, his anticipation is really poor.'
'And because he doesn't play the ball, Yoro, it could be outside the box but it is a red card. It's so clumsy from Yoro, he makes a lot of these kinds of mistakes.'
Naivety and exposure
According to Neville, Yoro had displayed great 'naivety' in getting himself sent off so early in the Premier League contest. 'He's not happy with it, Mauricio Pochettino,' the ex-England international continued. 'You could argue with it, Isak just delays slightly to make sure that Yoro runs into the back of him. But unfortunately, when you're a young defender, you're going to get caught like that and it's naivety.'
Switching his focus back to De Ligt, Neville said the Netherlands international had likely been 'exposed' as a result of playing so little football over the last 12 months. 'We saw it against Como and he's been out for a year, trying to come back to this level of football. It's really tough,' he went on.
'To have De Ligt out there in a game like this, in a back four, he's been exposed inside the first ten minutes. I have to say, Yoro's positioning covering is really poor. It's poor. Yoro has got to be across and around the other centre-back. You've got to cover your mate and he doesn't. It's really just bad all round from Manchester United.'
Neville's Sky Sports colleague Jamie Carragher was similarly unimpressed by United's defending, branding the visitors' start 'absolutely shocking'. 'It's as bad as it gets from two centre-backs,' the former Liverpool and England defender said. 'The ball from Ronald Araujo… it wasn't even a pass, it's just a clearance, a hopeful ball through the middle. Absolutely shocking.'