Murphy warns Liverpool against £100m Alex Scott transfer move
Murphy warns Liverpool off £100m Alex Scott move

Former Liverpool midfielder Danny Murphy has advised the club against spending big money on Bournemouth's Alex Scott in the January transfer window, arguing that tactical adjustments are a greater priority than new signings.

Murphy, who was part of Gerard Houllier's treble-winning Reds squad of 2001, believes Cherries boss Andoni Iraola can find the right blend on the training pitch rather than moving into the market. Scott turned down a contract offer at Bournemouth earlier this year and has been linked with both Chelsea and Liverpool amid reports of a £100m price tag.

Murphy questions Scott's fit

Murphy, who made 249 appearances for Liverpool between 1997 and 2004, said Iraola, who coached the England international during his time in charge of Bournemouth, should look inward rather than spending heavily.

"I don't see Alex Scott as a defensive midfielder, and Adam Wharton, who is more of a classic defensive midfielder, isn't playing particularly well at the moment," Murphy told PariuriX.com.

"And probably, if you look at the best midfielders in Europe, does he have the athletic qualities you need to be a top defensive midfielder? Like a Moises Caicedo, like a Declan Rice?"

Midfield discipline concerns

Murphy added: "He is a delightful footballer whom I admire, but I don't think he has the athletic ability to play that role in a team that wants to push forward and attack, because you have to cover a huge area of the pitch."

"I think at this moment, if you prioritise what you need, it's not so much about the players as tactical adjustments. To make them a bit harder to beat and make sure that one of those midfielders, whether it's (Trey) Nyoni, (Alexis) Mac Allister, or (Ryan) Gravenberch, is more disciplined."

"At this moment, it feels as if the midfielders are free to go and do anything to win matches. Unfortunately, that doesn't make you a cohesive team."

Gravenberch's role highlighted

Murphy also believes Gravenberch still has the ability to shine at the base of the midfield, where he operated with distinction when Liverpool won the Premier League two seasons ago.

He added: "I don't think the midfield is necessarily just about the players. I think I saw in Arne Slot's title team that these players can be more solid and compact. Obviously, that didn't go as well in the second season."

"Tactics, I believe, are the biggest problem at the moment. I find it a bit confusing, considering you can see how Gravenberch handled that role in that season (24/25). Why not try to replicate that when you need someone? He showed he can do it with a bit more discipline. Why not try again? I'd love to see that."

Liverpool return to action when they host Manchester United on Sunday afternoon.