Manchester United manager Mauricio Pochettino and his players have defended Leny Yoro after he was sent off just seven minutes into the 4-0 defeat to Liverpool at Anfield. The defender was dismissed in the first half when he brought down Alexander Isak on the edge of the box.
Matthijs de Ligt misjudged a long ball by Ronald Araujo, allowing the former Newcastle United striker a free run at goalkeeper Senne Lammens. Yoro raced back to cover his centre-half partner before bundling into the back of Isak and bringing him down.
Referee Sam Barrott showed a red card for the denial of a goalscoring opportunity, sending the 21-year-old off. The incident was reviewed by the Video Assistant Referee, John Brooks, and his assistant at Stockley Park, who confirmed the on-field decision.
Premier League explains VAR decision
The Premier League Match Centre explained the decision, writing on X: "The referee's call of red card to Yoro for denial of an obvious goal-scoring opportunity (DOGSO) was checked and confirmed by VAR."
"It's a red card for DOGSO. On-field decision is outside [the box], red card, DOGSO," said the referee at the time. VAR added: "Defender bundles into him into the back, gets too tight, I think it's a foul."
Dominik Szoboszlai scored the resulting free-kick. The dismissal drew opposing views among pundits, but the United camp came out fighting after the full-time whistle.
Neville, Carragher and Keane split
Gary Neville and Jamie Carragher agreed with the decision. Neville said: "Yoro should be across; he has to get further round, he has to cover and he doesn't. He reacts late. His anticipation is really poor. It's so clumsy from Yoro; he makes a lot of these types of mistakes. It's naivety. He just needs to get off the pitch. You're not going to get that turned around, no chance."
Carragher described the mix-up at the back as 'as bad as it gets that from two centre-backs'. He added: "The ball from [Araújo] was not even a pass; it was just [a] clearance, a hopeful ball through the middle. Absolutely shocking." Danny Murphy said there was 'no doubt' about the dismissal.
Roy Keane disagreed, insisting Isak was not getting the ball. He said: "Isak's not getting the ball. It's really poor defending. Players not smelling danger. But Isak is not getting that ball. Absolutely not. It's clumsy from United. Obviously it's one straight ball over the top. You shouldn't be in so much trouble. But there's no way he's getting that ball. Absolutely not. I know Isak is quick and he's sharp, but we've looked at it again."
Pochettino and players respond
Pochettino told Sky Sports: "The ball was for the goalkeeper. In that situation, if you review the VAR, you can see for sure, he never had the intention to connect with Isak. When the control was long with the striker, the ball was going to the goalkeeper; he runs and goes down. In Leny's case, it wasn't intentional. It was an unusual situation that is normal; everyone who plays football can feel it. If you look before, on the sixth minute. Jacquet on Mbeumo. Similar? No. If you compare the actions, that was a penalty. How that changes life, if you score after six minutes. Now, for sure, we are talking in a different way. We have to take responsibility; I take the responsibility. We keep pushing. It's not going to change what happened. Being respectful is the most important. At the same time, I have to defend my club. And tell what I feel. That was an action that everyone who plays football, it was clear that a situation that was not a red card."
Bruno Fernandes told Sky Sports: "It's one that needs to be looked at. We have far too many meetings with the referees for this to happen to us again. The last one against Chelsea [when Lisandro Martinez was sent off], you can give it as a red card and it was probably a second yellow also. Today, you can't give a red card. It's very clear they show us if the player is not in control of the ball, it's never a red card. Isak kicks the ball forward, the ball goes into the hands of Senne. Isak has got no control of the ball, he has no chance to get on the ball. He puts his leg across to try to get some advantage from Leny. I can understand the fall, but it's never a red card. There are too many referees on the pitch and too many on VAR taking so long to see to make a mistake like this that can change the game. It's not because of them we conceded the goal from the free-kick, but it changes the game completely."
Kobbie Mainoo added: "Absolutely no chance Leny Yoro's challenge was a red card. Never. The ball was already with the keeper; they're both running full speed, what can he do?"
Former referee calls decision subjective
Former FIFA and Premier League referee Mark Halsey reviewed the incident in an interview with The Sun. He said: "We saw an early card at Anfield as Liverpool faced Manchester United. Referee Sam Barrott sent off Manchester United's Leny Yoro for denying Alexander Isak an obvious goalscoring opportunity. Now, under Law 12, Fouls and Misconduct, what the referee has to consider in these situations is the distance between the offence and the goal, the general direction of play, the likelihood of the player keeping or gaining control of the ball, and the location and number of defenders. When you look at it in real time, does Isak take a heavy touch, allowing Manchester United goalkeeper Senne Lammens to come out and gather the ball? Now, for me, there is doubt as to whether Isak is going to keep or gain control of that ball after that heavy touch. It is subjective. VAR is not going to get involved because it's not a clear and obvious error. So I think there is doubt over whether Isak is going to keep or gain control of the ball once he's had that heavy touch."