The Premier League's Key Match Incident (KMI) Panel has ruled that a penalty should not have been awarded against Liverpool in their 3-1 Premier League win at Crystal Palace before the international break. The rock-bottom Eagles reduced the deficit in injury-time when Eddie Nketiah scored from the spot.
The penalty was awarded after referee Tony Harrington adjudged Reds left-back Milos Kerkez to have fouled Palace winger Dario Osario in the box, even though to most observers it appeared to be an innocent clash of heads.
Iraola's frustration vindicated
Despite seeing his side record a victory that took them up to fourth in the standings, Liverpool head coach Andoni Iraola was furious. But he will at least be vindicated by the KMI panel's verdict on the incident. The panel voted 5:0 in favour of it being an incorrect decision by Harrington.
In their reasoning, they wrote: "The panel unanimously felt that the referee's call of a penalty for a challenge by Kerkez on Osorio was incorrect with the contact being inevitable given the jumping actions of both players."
But the panel, which comprises one representative from the Premier League, one from Pro Ref and three independents, made up of former players and managers, did not consider it to be a clear and obvious error, meaning the VAR's lack of intervention was correct. They said: "However, the non-intervention of VAR was supported on the basis it was not a clear and obvious error."
Other incidents reviewed
The previous week the KMI panel had ruled that the Reds should have been awarded a penalty against Arsenal for a shirt pull on Alexander Isak. And speaking after Liverpool bounced back to winning ways at Selhurst Park, Iraola said: "I am very upset because the ones in our box they are calling penalties and in the other box they are now. I know we are 3-0 and it's the 95th minute but I'm very upset.
"It's a head to head but even then it's Osario to Milos. It's a clash of heads. You can say it's 3-0 but, for me, there is more because it is not the first time this season and you compare... I'm really upset.
"The VAR took a lot of time. When you call a penalty and they are two minutes. Two repetitions, three repetitions, they are finding a way not to be called by the VAR. A clean sheet is not cheap in the Premier League and we wanted to win 3-0.
"It is not just because of this penalty, it's because of a lot of things."
The KMI panel also reviewed two further incidents in the contest. They unanimously (5:0) supported the decisions to rule out Palace striker Jorgen Strand Larsen's first-half effort for offside and not to send Reds midfielder Alexis Mac Allister off for a challenge on Adam Wharton.
Liverpool return to action on Sunday when they welcome Manchester United to Anfield (4.30pm kick-off).