Hackett questions Barrott appointment for Liverpool vs Man United
Hackett questions Barrott Liverpool vs Man United appointment

Former Premier League referee Keith Hackett has questioned the appointment of Sam Barrott as the official for Liverpool vs Manchester United this weekend. Barrott is set to take charge of one of English football's most famous matches, having already irked the Reds this season.

Hackett, the former chief executive of the PGMOL (now known as Pro Ref), praised the 34-year-old's ability but admitted his confusion over the fact that Barrott will have refereed half of Liverpool's Premier League games at Anfield this term. The official was in charge for matches against Nottingham Forest and Brighton.

Third Anfield Appointment in Months

Since January 2024, Barrott has taken charge of seven Liverpool games, but after the weekend the Yorkshire-born ref will have blown the full-time whistle three times in a matter of months. Hackett is critical of the process that has allowed that.

"A top-class referee, but not a very good appointing procedure by his bosses," he said on X.

Barrott will be joined by Adam Nunn and Lee Betts as his assistants on Sunday, while Chris Kavanagh is the fourth official. John Brooks is on VAR duty and will be assisted by Paul Howard.

Alisson Penalty Controversy

Barrott has not won many fans despite his regular appearances on Merseyside, after awarding Nottingham Forest a penalty earlier this season when ex-Red Neco Williams went down under a challenge from goalkeeper Alisson Becker. That decision sparked fury from the shotstopper, who took his anger out on the substitution board, causing it to malfunction.

The Brazilian was sanctioned by the FA for his outburst and was fined £8,000. In some respects, it turns out Alisson's anger was justified.

The Premier League's Key Match Incidents Panel said in the aftermath that a penalty should not have been awarded. Though that was not a unanimous ruling.

They noted: "The panel felt that the referee’s call of a penalty was incorrect on-field, 3:2. The contact from Alisson was inevitable as a consequence of his momentum in attempting to save the ball – the contact made was not reckless and below the threshold for a penalty."

"However, the non-intervention by the VAR was unanimously supported on the basis that it was not a clear and obvious error."

Former Official Backs Barrott's Call

Former Premier League official Dermot Gallagher believed that Barrott made the correct decision. He said: "Alisson did the same tackle versus Man City against Matheus Nunes last season, he brought the player down and the referee gave the penalty."

"The same thing here: the referee gave the penalty. Both are penalties."