Former Premier League referee Graham Scott calls Goodison Park most hostile ground
Graham Scott: Goodison Park was most hostile ground

Retired Premier League referee Graham Scott has revealed that he considers Goodison Park to be the most hostile ground he ever officiated at during his career.

The 58-year-old retired last year after a decade refereeing in the English top-flight. He oversaw 107 Premier League matches in that time, running the rule over Everton on 13 occasions, with eight of those games coming at Goodison Park. Scott has now shared how much he enjoyed officiating at the Blues' former home.

Scott's verdict on Goodison

Appearing on The Athletic's podcast, Scott picked Goodison when asked if there were any particular stadiums or clubs where it was more difficult to withstand the pressure and stay neutral.

“The most hostile ground used to be Goodison,” he said. “Partly because of its geography, in that everything was very tight, and partly because people in the crowd were all up for the game.

“And you do get that at some stadiums more than others, where there is kind of a sense of people sitting back to be entertained.

“Old Trafford became very sanitised for a time, where it just felt like everyone was just waiting to be entertained or only there to complain about the owners rather than the ref. So from a refereeing point of view, it could be quite straightforward.

“But Goodison was always really tight, but I guess in your own mind you need to be strong, be resolute and make sure you do the right thing.

“That's how I would have approached it. And I enjoyed refereeing there. I thought it was a great place to ref and a great atmosphere. Every time I went there, it was brilliant.”

Home bias and VAR evidence

Scott also claimed that VAR evidence does suggest there tends to be a level of home bias from officials in matches, but disputed that referees favour bigger clubs.

“Of course it could be a thing,” he conceded. “The evidence of VAR would actually suggest there is some home bias going on, in that VAR tends to be correcting more in favour of the away team because there are more errors against the away team.

“So there is something in it. I'm not sure about the bigger club (enjoying refereeing bias in their favour), but I would say that, wouldn't I?

“I don't know where the truth lies, but there's certainly no organised sense of, 'We need to look after these people' or not look after them.

“You get on that field and it's reds against blues or yellows against greens and that's it. You're not bothered by who's who.”

Everton record under Scott

Everton won five of their matches officiated by Scott, including four at Goodison, and suffered eight defeats, with the heaviest loss a 5-2 home defeat at the hands of Watford in October 2021.

He was also responsible for issuing two stoppage-time penalties in the Blues' 3-2 victory over the Hornets in November 2017, as Leighton Baines scored what proved to be a 91st-minute winner as Everton fought back from 2-0 down, before Tom Cleverley later sent his own spot-kick wide.

Scott also sent off Seamus Coleman for two yellow card offences when the Blues lost 1-0 away at Burnley in October 2019. His most recent match involving Everton before his retirement was the Blues' League Cup quarter-final loss on penalties to Fulham at Goodison in December 2023.