Charlton Athletic manager Nathan Jones is among several head coaches across English football's top four divisions who have objected to a reduction in the number of yellow cards that leads to a touchline ban.
Standard Sport understands that at a recent managers' meeting, Jones and other head coaches from clubs among the 92 argued that a 2023 change in FA rules towards stricter punishments for technical-area misconduct remains unjustified at a time when football managers face greater pressure and volatility than ever before.
Managers question the timing of stricter rules
It is the view of some managers, including Jones, that the FA's move to bring forward touchline bans from four yellow cards to three is incongruous with an increasingly demanding working environment. Head coaches across the Premier League and EFL are understood to have been shown research this season suggesting that managers' behaviour usually improves once they reach three bookings.
Managers are regularly reminded of various regulations, including technical-area misconduct rules, during meetings with the FA's disciplinary teams, who often present research and statistics to contextualise changes to rules or emerging trends.
Background of the rule change
Ahead of the 2018-19 season, new rules were introduced to clean up touchline behaviour. Managers across the FA Cup, EFL, Carabao Cup, EFL Trophy and National League could receive yellow and red cards for the first time, with four yellows resulting in a one-match touchline ban. Premier League managers would receive only verbal cautions for "irresponsible behaviour", but the top flight fell in line with the same level of punishment from 2019-20 onwards.
A further update was made ahead of the 2023-24 campaign when the FA launched a new 'Participant Behaviour Charter' as part of its 'Love Football, Protect the Game' campaign, developed alongside the Premier League, EFL, Women's Super League, Women's Championship, National League System (Steps 1–4), and PGMOL (now Pro Ref), with input from the League Managers Association (LMA) and Professional Footballers' Association (PFA). The charter's aim was to improve the image of the game and maintain a positive environment. Four yellows for a managerial suspension was reduced to three and has remained so ever since.
New cut-off introduced this season
A new cut-off for technical-area cautions was introduced this season. Managers who receive their third technical-area booking after the 37th round of EFL league matches do not incur an immediate suspension. At that point, an automatic one-match touchline ban is triggered only if a fourth yellow card is picked up in a subsequent game.
Compared with its peak, the number of technical-area cautions issued has decreased by 17 per cent since the introduction of the 'Participation Behaviour Charter', FA sources say. Under the FA's 'Laws of the Game', other staff and substitutes in a technical area can also be cautioned or even sent off.
In certain circumstances, managers and head coaches can get booked or sent off on behalf of the misconduct of others in their technical area if the fourth official reports a situation deserving of punishment to the referee but cannot verify who in the technical area committed the offence. In such situations, FA rules state cards can be shown to the "manager or most senior coach in [the technical] area". The FA have been approached for comment.