Sandpapergate memory dispute: neither Cummins nor Khawaja may be lying
Sandpapergate: neither Cummins nor Khawaja may be lying

The conflicting recollections of Pat Cummins and Usman Khawaja over the 2018 Cape Town sandpaper scandal may not mean one of them is lying, according to a professor of memory.

Prof John Sutton, director of the Centre for the Sciences of Place and Memory at the University of Stirling, said it is "perfectly possible that there's nobody involved here who's not telling the truth as they see it."

Sutton was speaking before Cameron Bancroft's newspaper column in which he claimed the entire Australian Test team knew about the use of sandpaper during the 2018 tour of South Africa. Cummins' management team responded that there was nothing in the Bancroft statement that had not been answered in Cummins' press conference, where he denied any knowledge.

The Nature of Memory

Sutton, a cricket fan who was in Cape Town watching the infamous 2018 Newlands Test, said people's recollections differ because of what happened at the time of encoding and what happens at the time of retrieval. "Even if a player has kept a diary of what happened at the time they are still retrieving a narrative, a sequence of events, from the past," he said.

He described the pervading "sense of sadness" in watching the relationships of current and former players, notably Cummins and Khawaja, torn apart by the saga. The prevailing view among commentators and the general public is that one of the two must be lying about what happened in South Africa in 2018.

Sutton said that even at the time people were experiencing different things, and the emotional significance of what they were facing was different.

Differing Accounts

There is a clear splintering between the batters and bowlers who were in the Australian dressing room in Cape Town. Both sides have former teammates and coaches backing their version of events unequivocally. This week, reserve fast bowler Chadd Sayers and then-assistant coach Graeme Hick added their voices.

Hick went on record to state that Khawaja's claim that the entire dressing room was in on the plot is "absolutely false", while Sayers told Australian radio station SEN: "Everyone in that side knew what was going on and what was being used. [Sandpaper] was used in two Test matches and there were discussions in the changing rooms." Sayers stated that after the Cape Town Test match the entire team spent "60-90 minutes" in the changing rooms discussing what had happened.

Remembering Together

Sutton explained that remembering the past together with other people can have good and bad consequences. "On the one hand, the reason that witnesses aren't allowed to talk to each other before they go into court, say, when they've witnessed a crime, is that your story can get sort of condensed and converge and become a kind of fixed, rigid narrative that might encode some errors," he said.

"But also, collaboration can have a really good outcome if you get to kind of test your memories of events and how you feel about them, your emotions about events, against those of other people who might have a different take, who might have felt or experienced things differently."

Sutton said that with events that are highly dramatic and highly significant and emotional, memory can get trapped and fixated. He referenced psychologist Frederic Bartlett's 1932 experiments, including one where participants repeated a traditional Native American folktale to each other, and the memory of it changed with each retelling. The name of that story was War of the Ghosts.