Cameron Bancroft has broken nearly a decade of silence to accuse Test captain Pat Cummins of misleading the public over Australia's 2018 ball-tampering scandal, publishing a detailed account in the West Australian newspaper that names coaches and teammates in the cheating plot.
Bancroft, the former Test opening batsman, said he was pushed to speak by Cummins' press conference last week, in which the captain was adamant he had never been aware of any ball-tampering in Australian colours. "It made me feel angry, betrayed and alone," Bancroft wrote. "What I saw, experienced and lived with not only him, but everyone else on that tour in South Africa is not the public account he gave in his press conference and in the years previously."
Details of the Scandal
Bancroft confirms that David Warner was the instigator of using sandpaper on the match ball, per Cricket Australia's sanctions at the time, a fact omitted from Usman Khawaja's autobiography. He claims head coach Darren Lehmann, who has always denied knowledge, was present in conversations about sandpaper use and ordered reserve player Peter Handscomb to remove evidence from the field after Bancroft was caught. The bowling coach, David Saker, is named as the driver of the idea among the staff, while media manager Kate Hutchison is described as the one person in Cricket Australia's employ to speak against the practice.
Bancroft describes his illegal ball-tampering work as being discussed freely at a morning meeting with the entire team, with reverse swing a continuing conversation point between him, wicketkeeper Tim Paine, and the team's four seamers. He names Mitchell Marsh as being delighted at getting extravagant movement on his way to two crucial wickets in a session during the second Test of the series.
Admission of Lying
Bancroft admits to lying in his interview with Cricket Australia investigators in 2018 to conceal the breadth of complicity, restricting blame to himself, Warner, and captain Steve Smith, and restricting the scope of cheating to the third Test in Cape Town. The implication is either that those interviewed colluded ahead of time to get their stories lined up, or that someone along the line at Cricket Australia distorted the results to limit fallout.
Public contempt is directed at Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood, and Nathan Lyon, seen as potential liars as the only players to have publicly denied all knowledge. Bancroft leaves them one window: "I recognise there is a distinction between knowing a ball is reversing, suspecting it has been altered and knowing specifically that sandpaper has been used."
Coaches Under Scrutiny
Initial scrutiny should skip the players and start at the top, with the tour's coaches. The batting coach, Graeme Hick, is the only other tour member to deny all knowledge, while fielding coach Brad Haddin hasn't said a word. Lehmann told ABC radio after Bancroft's publication that he was considering his response before absenting himself from the rest of its broadcast of the one-day international against England. Saker said nothing lately but gently implicated himself in 2021: "There was a lot of people to blame. It could have been me to blame, it could have been someone else … We all know that we made a monumental mistake."
Cummins' management issued a statement on his behalf reiterating his position from last week: "Whilst we feel for Cam and everything he's been through there's nothing in the statement that hasn't been answered by Pat in his press conference."
The "independent forum" that Cricket Australia proposed before Bancroft's publication is better than the paralysis preceding it, but remains inadequate, being voluntary and private unless contributors and Cricket Australia agree to release information. The time for formal punishment is gone, but all those who lied while given the trust of a part in that team deserve to be known for what they've done. Let that be punishment enough.