The UK was “effectively blind” to the spread of Covid-19 because testing was not scaled up at the start of the pandemic, a public inquiry has found. Baroness Heather Hallett’s report on the test and trace response also heavily criticised ministers over border control policy.
Although scientists had developed an effective test by mid-January 2020, “there was no system of widespread testing, tracing or isolation for several months”, the report said. It added that “Covid-19 was allowed to spread with deadly speed across the country, virtually unchecked”.
Missed opportunity on borders
The report said the decision not to implement widespread border control measures from the outset “represented a missed opportunity by the UK Government to try to slow the spread of infection by reducing the risk of imported cases”. Lady Hallett argued that a 14-day self-isolation requirement for all incoming travellers “could have had a significant impact”, and that even suspending all flights from China in February 2020 could “have provided valuable additional time to prepare healthcare systems”.
The report noted that by April 2020, 93% of countries and territories had put measures in place, such as flight suspensions, border closures and travel restrictions. By contrast, the UK government only requested, rather than directed, travellers from Wuhan to self-isolate in January 2020 and travellers from some other high-risk areas in February 2020. This did not prevent a coachload of tourists from Wuhan entering the UK and travelling from England to Scotland and then to Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland in February 2020.
Testing capacity overwhelmed
Lady Hallett said the abandonment of contact tracing and testing in the community in March 2020 was due to the UK’s lack of tests, equipment and poor capacity to process them. In her foreword to the 245-page report, she said efforts to contain the virus early on “were doomed to fail” because the test, trace and isolate system could only handle a relatively small number of cases. “As the number of cases began to rise exponentially, capacity for testing, tracing and isolation was soon overwhelmed,” she said.
The inability to carry out widespread testing meant the “likelihood increased that more restrictive measures, such as lockdowns, would later be required”. When ministers realised the scale of the crisis, they “invested considerable time, effort and resources in developing a scaled-up system” which, once established, “was extremely effective”. However, initial efforts were hindered by a lack of planning, a lack of knowledge of existing testing capabilities, and a failure to work with the private and public sectors and local authorities.
Comparison with other countries
The inquiry found that countries including Singapore, Australia and Germany were “comparatively better prepared to respond to the emergence of Covid-19” and “experienced markedly lower death rates than the UK during the first six months of the pandemic”. The report said the decision to allow virtually unrestricted international travel in the first six months of 2020 came at a time when the UK had no mass testing or widespread contact tracing and its healthcare resources were stretched thin. “Overall, the UK was left in an extremely weak position from which to face the rapidly rising rates of infection,” it said.
UK Government statistics show that about 6.8 million people arrived in the UK by air in February 2020 and 3.8 million people in March 2020.
Impact on individuals
The report also found that when people were told to isolate, “many felt forgotten and let down by the lack of practical or financial support when trying to follow the rules”. Lady Hallett said she heard “distressing accounts from individuals who were faced with the unenviable choice of self-isolating and losing income, or going to work and risking spreading the virus”. The challenges associated with self-isolation were “foreseeable”, and planning for the financial and practical support required proved inadequate.
Lady Hallett said: “Too many lives were cut short. Too many died without the comfort of their loved ones around them.” She added that with proper planning, clear communication and a unified strategy, it is possible to build a robust and scalable test, trace and isolate system, which “will be fundamental to saving lives and reducing suffering”.