MP pushes mandatory nursery CCTV after serial abuser jailed
MP pushes mandatory nursery CCTV after abuser jailed

A London MP has stepped up pressure on the Government to make CCTV compulsory in nurseries to protect babies and toddlers, after a serial abuser was jailed earlier this year.

Former minister Tulip Siddiq tabled a draft law in the Commons to introduce the regulation, following the conviction of paedophile Vincent Chan. The 45-year-old preyed on children as young as two years old while they were in his care at the Bright Horizons nursery in Finchley Road, West Hampstead, north London.

Deterrent argument

Ms Siddiq, MP for Hampstead and Highgate, argued that the presence of CCTV could have acted as a deterrent to Chan, who sexually touched children while they were sleeping. The Government has previously said it is considering mandating CCTV in early years settings and will do “whatever we can do to keep children safe”.

A local child safeguarding practice review, launched in December last year, is expected to report back in the next few months, according to the Department for Education.

Chan's crimes

Chan was jailed for 18 years at Wood Green Crown Court in February for molesting young children over the course of 15 years. A Metropolitan Police investigation uncovered that Chan had taken upskirt videos of girls in class when he worked as a teaching assistant at St Mary’s Church of England School in Finchley.

He has confessed to spying on girls and women as they got undressed in their bedrooms and used the toilet, as well as sexually assaulting a woman as she slept. He also amassed a collection of at least 26,000 indecent images of children online, including clips of rape.

Parents' calls and concerns

Many parents have called for the change in the law to ensure children’s safety. However, then-Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson previously said it could lead to other forms of child abuse if footage was misused.

Ms Siddiq’s safety of nurseries (CCTV) Bill was brought forward through a 10-minute rule motion, and would need Government backing to become law.

She told the Commons: “The parents who know that their children were abused are having to face a life of trauma, counselling, therapy.

“There are also parents who have absolutely no idea what actually happened to their children, and in a way, they feel worse because the truth is, we may never find out what happened to their children.

“The only evidence that’s available to account for Vincent Chan’s crimes is the images that he took himself, the ones that he recorded and then kept and used for his purposes.

“There is no independent visual evidence to find out what he did and the extent of his crime.”

She added: “If he was taking pictures in a busy, crowded nursery and there was CCTV, that might have actually worked as a deterrent for Vincent Chan, thinking: ‘Should I be doing this because I could be caught?'”

Ms Siddiq also argued CCTV could have encouraged other nursery workers to report his behaviour, knowing there could be visual evidence to support their claims.