Andy Burnham's Mansion House speech this week, setting out his "EU reset," marks the biggest betrayal yet of the British people, according to columnist Carole Malone. Writing for the Daily Express, Malone argues that Burnham, now in No.10, secured his position by telling Leave-leaning voters in Makerfield that Brexit was done and he would not interfere with it, only to renege on that promise once in power.
Malone contends that Burnham's talk of a "Makerfield Test" for Labour policies rings hollow, as his constituents feel betrayed by his EU surrender and the loss of hard-won rights. She suggests that had he spoken to them before taking office, he would know they reject signing up to EU rules over which Parliament and the British people have no say.
Economic Claims and Counterclaims
Malone disputes Burnham's assertion that Brexit has caused Britain to lose more than it gained, pointing to predicted UK growth of 1.3% for 2026 against an EU average of 1.1%. She attributes the cost-of-living crisis and economic woes to Labour mismanagement, high taxes, Covid's impact on industry, and the cost of funding wars in Ukraine and Iran, rather than Brexit.
She highlights benefits of leaving the EU, including the ability to set laws, make trade deals (70 completed), and redirect funds to the NHS, which grew from £115 billion in 2019 to £200 billion now. Malone also notes a £30 billion penalty for leaving, with £5.7 billion still owed, and estimates the reset could cost £750 million a week.
Concerns Over Costs and Sovereignty
Malone questions the financial wisdom of the reset, citing a £3 trillion UK debt and warnings from the IMF to curb spending. She notes the EU's own financial troubles, including breached funding rules and parliamentary deadlock over budget contributions.
She criticises the loss of sovereignty, predicting two new EU laws daily over which Britain would have no say, and cites the Growth Commission Think Tank, which says minor trade benefits would be outweighed by associated costs. Malone also raises concerns about increased migration, university bailouts, and restrictions on deporting foreign criminals.
In closing, Malone argues that Burnham has revealed himself as a poor negotiator by showing desperation to rejoin, and she suggests the British public would vote to leave again if they knew the true cost.