Andy Burnham is heading towards a direct confrontation with Angela Rayner over plans to get young people off benefits and into work, and he cannot afford to lose, according to a political analysis.
Rayner has never been afraid of a fight, a trait that suited her first role as a union rep. As she puts it, “I was mouthy, and I would take no messing from management.” In a February 2020 campaign video, she used the slogan: “I've fought my whole life. I'll never stop fighting. And I fight to win.”
However, she went too far the following year by calling senior Tories “scum”, a remark she initially defended as working-class “street language” before issuing an apology. Rayner also called the Tories “homophobic, racist, misogynist, absolutely vile…”, showing that in a fight with Red Ange, there are no holds barred.
Burnham's approach to conflict
In contrast to Rayner, Burnham is better known for being affable and approachable, the ultimate Mr Nice Guy. He prefers to dodge conflict and seek consensus, repeatedly using the phrase “problem-solving, not point-scoring”. He did call Tories “zombies” when attacking Boris Johnson’s Brexit deal, but that’s as rough as it gets.
Former PM Keir Starmer did find the courage to sack Rayner over her stamp duty issue, but it didn’t do him much good. Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood also folded when Rayner went after her.
Youth employment plans spark rebellion
Burnham faces a backbench rebellion over plans drawn up by former New Labour minister Alan Milburn to get young people off benefits and into work. Since 2024, Labour has made the situation worse through two policies: Rachel Reeves’s jobs tax made young people too expensive to employ, while Labour’s banning of “exploitative” zero-hour contracts made finding starter roles even harder.
New workers' rights in Rayner’s Employment Rights Act have made small businesses too terrified to take on untried staff, for fear of being stuck with them if they don't shape up.
Milburn has openly admitted that both measures have worsened the problems facing young people, warning they “have major implications at a time when the youth labour market is already weak”. Reeves is gone but Rayner is still around, and she won't like that.
Burnham backtracks on employment laws
At first, Burnham seemed to back Milburn's combative message, and suggested he was open to changing employment laws to make hiring young people easier. Then he quickly backtracked, saying there was a “balance to be struck” on the other side of the argument too.
If he's really going to soften employment laws, he’ll have to square up to Rayner, who won’t give an inch. The analysis concludes that Rayner will win again, and Burnham looks beaten before he’s even begun, which is a disaster both for his authority as PM and the country.