Andy Burnham's promise of a new, consensual politics has already unravelled, at least in his exchanges with Kemi Badenoch at prime minister's questions. The prime minister, who arrived in No 10 determined to work with other parties, now finds himself in a bloodless slanging match with the Tory leader, with nothing really at stake and both leaders playing to their own backbenchers.
A Performance for the Gallery
Badenoch has yet to land a blow on Burnham, and the exchanges have become a performance rather than a substantive debate. Even if Burnham were to concede she was right, Badenoch would still find a way to disagree, as she is hardwired for conflict and lost without someone to fight.
Both leaders are now on cruise control, with PMQs a jeopardy-free zone. Unlike Keir Starmer, who sometimes seemed at risk of falling apart on a Wednesday lunchtime, Burnham has no apparent weak spots that Badenoch has identified, and she does not seem interested in doing the work to find them.
Welfare and Point-Scoring
Badenoch chose to attack on welfare and Neets, asking when the welfare bill would come down and why everything the government did would take at least 10 years. Burnham initially tried to give a straight answer, explaining that the bill would not come down because of the way accounts were balanced, with some young people getting less in benefits but more in help to get back to work.
When Badenoch did not pay attention, Burnham resorted to point-scoring, suggesting she and the shadow work and pensions secretary, Helen Whately, were too dumb to understand anything and would not be happy until they saw someone really suffer by having their benefits removed.
Patronising Tone and the EU Deal
Badenoch countered that she understood everything perfectly and that the prime minister wanted welfare vibes, not welfare cuts. Burnham called for humility from the Tories, accusing Badenoch of choosing her facts selectively, and later said he had had enough of her patronising tone.
Badenoch also misunderstood the deal with the EU, assuming it meant 100,000 foreigners coming to the UK and no Brits going to Europe. The patronising tone is characteristic of Badenoch, a sign of endearment in her approach.
Some Tories imagined this was a major misstep by Burnham, but the real point was that he came across as the more human, likable politician. Labour remain a long way clear in the opinion polls, with most people thinking they are doing a decent job.
Home Secretary's Absence
The home secretary, Shabana Mahmood, was missing from this week's PMQs, attending a police chiefs' conference to give a speech on "two-tier policing." She did not say there was two-tier policing, but she did not say there was not, leaving the possibility of police that target everyone.