Kemi Badenoch has accused Prime Minister Andy Burnham of taking a “vibes-based” approach to welfare reform, saying he is giving young people “false hope.” The Conservative leader pressed Mr Burnham on rising benefit numbers during Prime Minister's Questions.
Mr Burnham pledged to do “everything that I can, as quickly as possible, to get the welfare bill down” when challenged by Mrs Badenoch. His comments came after Alan Milburn called for a shake-up of the benefits system to save £3.6 billion a year, with funding redirected to measures getting 16 to 24-year-olds into jobs or training.
Milburn review proposes youth allowance
Mr Burnham said his Government would set out a full response to the former Labour minister's review into youth unemployment next month. Mr Milburn's 10-year plan proposed reducing the number of 16 to 24-year-olds classified as not in education, employment or training (Neet) from its current level of around 13% – about a million people – to 5%.
The Government-commissioned report proposes an “entirely new benefit system for young people,” with a so-called youth allowance replacing both the health element of universal credit (UC) and personal independence payment (Pip) for 16 to 24-year-olds.
PM pressed on welfare cuts
Pressed on whether he would “cut welfare this Parliament,” Mr Burnham said: “I will do everything that I can as quickly as possible to get the welfare bill down.” He added: “I have asked the Cabinet to reprioritise spending plans for 2027-28 to put the beginnings of a fund together to support the youth opportunity service, initially delivering 25,000 quality work placements for 16 and 17-year-olds.”
Mrs Badenoch accused Mr Burnham of wanting “the vibes welfare reform without actually doing any welfare reform.” She said the Prime Minister and Mr Milburn appeared to be at odds on whether some young people will get less in benefits.
Exchange over youth schemes
Mr Burnham responded: “We are about helping young people into work, we are about giving young people hope and a better life – that is what this whole reform is about.”
Mrs Badenoch then said: “He says that he wants to give young people a better life. All he is offering them is false hope, because none of the things he is saying are going to work. He keeps talking about all of the Government schemes that they've got. The youth guarantee scheme is a complete and total failure, everyone out there knows it. They destroy jobs, they kill businesses, and then they offer the businesses a little money to give young people work placements. It makes no sense at all.”
Mr Burnham said the Government will respond to the Milburn report “in the round,” adding: “But if she is arguing here for a cuts-only approach, well, we will stand against that because we know that will not help a generation move on.”
EU youth mobility scheme row
Mrs Badenoch warned that a youth mobility scheme set to be agreed with the EU on Friday could flood Britain's labour market with European youngsters competing for entry-level jobs. He replied: “We do need jobs now, and that requires growth in the economy, and we know over the last decade when they were in Government we had a decade of low growth. Those are the facts. They go quiet because they know that is a fact, and the deal that's on the table will bring growth to the British economy.”
Mrs Badenoch then said she wanted to “clear up some confusion for the Prime Minister,” before adding: “Growth is created by the businesses who create the jobs. It is business that creates growth, not government. The growth comes after the jobs. It doesn't just happen.”
In his final response, Mr Burnham accused her of asking “self-serving questions” and taking a “patronising tone.” He added: “This side of the House is leading on the big issues, we will not let a lost generation be the letdown generation. We are acting to deal with these issues and to face them. And we will, yes, we will lead on Europe and bring growth to the British economy. This side believes in the next generation. That side wants to throw them on the scrap heap again.”